Come on Costco’s food court pizza is the stuff of legends, but the real magic happens in the freezer section. Those enormous, bargain priced pies are ideal for crazy nights, movie nights, or just indulging a craving without overpaying. Frozen pizzas get a bad name, but Costco has some serious winners that’ll make your go to delivery joint jealous. I’ve sifted through Reddit forums, internet chatter, and customer praise to deliver to you the 10 top frozen pizzas available at Costco. Roll out your cart and clear out some freezer space these pies are going to capture your heart!
1. Amnon’s New York Select Kosher Regular Pizza
If you’re searching for a Kosher pizza that gets that New York pizzeria atmosphere just right, Amnon’s is where it’s at. This two pack brings the Big Apple to your kitchen with handmade, oven baked crusts that scream authenticity. One Costco fan on Reddit couldn’t hold back: “That looks like real NY style pizza. I’d grab it in a heartbeat! ” It’s not just about taste it’s about inclusivity, offering a high quality option for Kosher diets.
Ideal for a speedy dinner or solo treat, this pizza’s a treasure for anyone hankering for that iconic New York slice.
2. Italpizza Margherita Pizza
Imagine yourself in Italy without having to venture out. Italpizza’s Margherita Pizza is available in a three pack for under $25, and it’s a bargain. These wood fired pizzas are topped with basil, baby mozzarella, juicy tomatoes, and a pinch of pesto. The pre cooked crust, cooked in an Italian wood fired oven, gets all crispy and provides a decadent snap with each bite. Others say the crust is good but not earth shattering, but for me, it’s all about the real Italian taste.
This pizza’s your ticket to a fancy European night in.
3. Bellatoria Sausage Italia Pizza
Sausage lovers, rejoice! Bellatoria’s Sausage Italia Pizza is a thin crust heaven in a three pack that’s ready when the craving hits. It has a cult following on the internet, where one Redditor vowed it’s a favorite of all frozen pizzas, not only Costco’s. Another warned me that it has a salty bite just what you want if you’re a fan of strong flavors. The extremely thin crust retains its crispiness, and the ample sausage topping ensures that each bite is a flavorful victory.
Stock up for those evenings when you crave a fast, tasty fix.
4. Sabatasso’s Thin Crust Pizza Singles
For solo meals or grab and go atmosphere, Sabatasso’s Thin Crust Pizza Singles come to the rescue. This 12 pack divides into six pepperoni and six four cheese minis, and here’s the best part they’re microwaveable! Costco shoppers were amazed at how excellent these are for only $0.87 per serving. There’s even a gluten free version for added convenience. They’re not gourmet, but when you’re in the mood for a quick, delicious bite, these mini pies hit the spot big time.
5. Sabatasso’s Gluten Free Pizza
If gluten’s not your best buddy, Sabatasso’s Gluten Free Pizza’s got you covered. It’s a decent choice for those avoiding gluten, but some of our users say it’s “okay but not spectacular.” Next to Costco’s trendier cauliflower crust offerings, this one’s softer, less crunchy, but it does the trick. It’s all about convenience providing a trusty option for gluten free individuals without costing flavor. Store it in your freezer for those evenings when pizza is on your mind, no exceptions.
6. Kirkland Signature Cheese Pizza
Breadcrumb Crust Who doesn’t enjoy a basic cheese pizza? Kirkland Signature’s take, complete with its distinctive breadcrumb crust, is a crowd pleaser in a four pack. It’s affordable and great for families or supplementing with your own favorite toppings. Reddit users praise the taste sauce and crispy crust, though some criticise the cheese as a bit waxy. One customer said it was the “best for the price” and enjoys putting her own twist, such as BBQ chicken or pineapple.
It’s a clean slate for your pizza fantasies!
7. Kirkland Signature Pepperoni Pizza, Thin Crust
Pepperoni fanatics, rejoice. Kirkland’s Pepperoni Thin Crust Pizza is sold in a four pack, and pepperoni is packed on no stinting on the toppings here! One Redditor raved, “There’s actually enough pepperoni to cover the pizza!” The thin crust remains crunchy, and the melty cheese holds it together for a traditional pie that outdoes most frozen varieties. At around $3.37 apiece, it’s a bargain for a fast, filling meal that’s a crowd pleaser.
8. Milton’s Cauliflower Crust Pizza
Veggie enthusiasts and gluten free individuals, say hello to your new addiction: Milton’s Cauliflower Crust Roasted Vegetable Pizza. This two pack is loaded with roasted zucchini, bell peppers, onions, and a creamy three cheese blend. The cauliflower crust is crunchy and does not shout “healthy,” so it’s a flavor and texture victory. It’s a nutritious option that doesn’t cut corners on flavor, raving for its colorful toppings and upscale feel.
At approximately $6 per pizza, it’s a necessity for nights filled with veggies.
9. Kirkland Signature Cauliflower Crust Pizza, Supreme
If you’re missing Costco’s food court Combo Pizza, the Kirkland Signature Cauliflower Crust Supreme Pizza is the solution. The two pack, which costs around $11.99, is stuffed with pepperoni, sausage, roasted vegetables, and a blend of three cheeses. The cauliflower crust is a revelation crunchy, neutral, and solid enough to hold all those toppings. One Redditor confessed, “I never thought I’d love a cauliflower pizza, but these are delicious!” It’s a supreme experience that’s equally tasty and affordable.
10. Motor City Pizza Co. Double Pepperoni Deep Dish Pizza
Keep your pizza cutters close this is the big one! Motor City’s Double Pepperoni Deep Dish Pizza is Costco’s frozen pizza MVP. This Detroit style two pack comes with a dense, crispy chewy crust and a pepperoni excess that’s gained a huge following. Someone on Reddit referred to it as “better than delivery,” and for another, it’s “the best frozen pizza, hands down.” Let’s be honest, for $7.50 per pizza, it’s a cheesy, rectangular masterpiece, lasagna meets pizza.
11. Roncadin Mushroom & Truffle Pizza
For a gourmet indulgence, Roncadin’s Mushroom & Truffle Pizza is heaven. This pie, which boasts garlicky truffle mushroom sauce and cheese, is a crowd pleaser. One Redditor described it as, “It’s a 10 out of 10!” You can spice it up with a drizzle of truffle oil or a sprinkle of Parmesan flakes. It’s an unconventional pizza without red sauce, ideal for adventurous foodies who want to take their dinner to the next level.
Why You’ll Love Costco’s Frozen Pizzas
Costco’s freezer aisle is a pizza lover’s treasure trove. From singles for a quick fix to gluten free marvels and deep dish legends, there’s a pie for any whim. These pies aren’t just convenient they’re about generous flavors, good value, and making your weeknights (or game nights) infinitely better. The next time you’re rolling that massive cart, stop by the frozen aisle. Your taste buds and calendar will appreciate stocking up on these saucy, cheesy treats. Enjoy pizza! Check it out: Fire Up the Grill: Your Guide to the Best Hot Dogs and Summer BBQ Essentials, The 10 Unbeatable Costco Dinner Staples That Have Saved My Weeknights For 17 Years, The 7 Frozen Pizzas You’ll Ever Have in 2025, Costco Shoppers Are Obsessed With These Frozen Dinners, And We Get It, The Trader Joe’s and Costco Finds Sparking Major Cravings and Shopping Sprees
