Unlocking Five Guys’ Hidden Delights: Some Secret Menu Hacks & Insider Secrets You Need to Know

Folks enjoy Five Guys quite a lot, you know. The burgers, fries, and peanuts evoke a sense of good times. Yet, this famous place holds secrets beyond the cooked patties. Hidden delights lie beyond what the menu shows. Discovering these simply enhances the quality of your usual visit greatly.

Yes, these secret menus are quite fun, you know. Adventurous eaters customize their normal orders quite freely, you know. This builds loyalty and perfects the taste of the food, you see. Some chains display lists, but Five Guys hides its offerings well. Word-of-mouth helps fans uncover its potential.

If standard food bores you, this list is for you. We searched hard to find these hidden opportunities, you know. Here is a list of items you can request. These tasty discoveries prove that Five Guys offers quite a lot of pleasant surprises.

1. **The Double Grilled Cheeseburger**: The Double Grilled Cheeseburger offers quite a hearty meal, you know. It’s based on the popular grilled cheeseburger item that’s already well-known. That grilled cheese version uses an inside-out burger bun.

Flipping the bun gives it a very good texture when eaten. Adding one patty made the first viral item notable. This new version includes two burger patties inside, you know. That definitely satisfies really hungry people quite easily.

It contains much more cheese than regular burgers offer. More cheese makes it extra gooey and nice to eat. You can add tons of free toppings that you like.

2. **The Patty Melt**: **The Patty Melt**: It is loved but not on the list. It skillfully combines grilled cheese and burger components. Instead of a normal burger bun, it uses bread. Five Guys uses upside-down burger buns to make their cheese bread. Just ask for grilled cheese and then add a patty, you’ll see. You’ll get that special grilled bun feel along with the burger. Many fans really swear by this popular off-menu item.

3. **The Chicago-Style Hot Dog Hack**: The Chicago-Style Hot Dog Hack starts with underrated hot dogs. They split the hot dogs lengthwise before grilling them. This adds a lot of flavor and char to the hot dog, you see.

Free toppings allow you to build the famous regional hot dog you want. You can easily add pickles, tomatoes, onions, mustard, relish, peppers, and salt. All these toppings are completely free for you to use.

Some die-hard Chicago fans might have minor nitpicks, you know. They mention special buns or specific peppers that they think are necessary. This hack makes it fairly easy for folks to get a taste of Chicago outside of the city.

4. **Employee Secret Fries (Ro-Tel Inspired Hack)**: Employee Secret Fries (Ro-Tel Inspired Hack) originated from a viral employee trick. It utilizes kitchen ingredients that are easily found there, you see. This gives Five Guys’ fries a completely new flavor twist.

Take the standard fries and add a savory mixture as a topping. The mixture contains ground beef cooked with onions and peppers. Then, melted cheese is added on top, followed by seasoning. It feels like a very elevated fry-eating experience.

The idea came from Ro-Tel fries, which are popular in the south, you see. Traditional Ro-Tel uses Velveeta cheese and ground beef. This hack, however, uses readily available cheese and beef/vegetable components instead. Still, it offers a really cool trick for fans to know about.

5. **The Classic Grilled Cheeseburger**: The Classic Grilled Cheeseburger was the first viral item, you know. It simply adds one patty to the special grilled cheese. It skillfully combines the unique components that Five Guys provides. The grilled cheese base truly is an important part of this, you know.

It uses those crispy inside-out burger buns. Plus, there’s surely gooey melted American cheese inside. Add a seasoned patty for a hybrid experience, you see. It feels like a burger inside a grilled cheese.

This item became popular online, you know. It showed that simple changes can really work well. It paved the way for the double patty item later. Combining items creates something new and exciting, you see.

6. **It’s Always Bagged Up, No Trays Here!**: At Five Guys, you always receive a paper bag. This occurs whether you dine in or take your food out. Trays are never provided. Not even if you choose to sit right at a table. This system is part of their customer service approach.

At Five Guys, the brown bag strategy is more than just packaging. It allows them to intentionally overfill your fry order. This is a favorite aspect among fans. Plenty of hot, greasy fries are placed directly into the bag. They spill over onto your burger, coating everything with a delicious aroma. This overflow gives you the impression of receiving a generous portion. It’s like getting a great deal, you know. It enhances the customers’ satisfaction with their food.

This sets Five Guys apart from other establishments. Other places change their packaging for dining in or out. However, the same paper bag maintains that classic atmosphere. It makes the visit consistent. You feel excited when you see that greasy bag. It’s filled with the potential for deliciousness.

7. **They Used to Say “Absolutely No Delivery”**: Today, getting food delivered is very common. Apps like DoorDash make it easy for us. However, Five Guys did not offer delivery for a long time. They really resisted the idea. They felt that delivery would compromise the quality. Owner Jerry Murrell stated this himself. He believed it would diminish the value of the product.

This was not just empty talk from him. When the first store opened near D.C. in 1986, they adhered to this principle. A general once attempted to order burgers for delivery. He wanted 15 hamburgers to be sent to the Pentagon. But Jerry Murrell refused immediately. He even placed a big sign outside the first store. It boldly stated, “Absolutely No Delivery” for everyone to see.

Nowadays, it seems surprising given the prevalence of delivery services. Five Guys now does deliver through various apps. That old resistance, like refusing the general’s order, shows their strong commitment. They really wanted to control the customer’s experience. They wanted the food to be enjoyed as intended. This is an interesting aspect of their brand’s history.

8. **Those Peanuts Aren’t Just a Snack, They’re a Strategy!**: Walking into Five Guys gives you plenty to sense. There’s the red-and-white decor. The smell of burgers is enticing. Then there are free peanuts in boxes everywhere. These free peanuts are a unique feature. They’re also a favorite part of the waiting experience. You can grab a tray and shell them happily. These peanuts do more than just satisfy your hunger.

The official reason for offering free peanuts is simple. It provides customers with a snack while they wait for their food. Every burger and fry order is made fresh. This takes a bit longer than at other fast-food places. The chain serves a huge quantity of peanuts weekly. Reports say it’s 260,000 pounds each week. This waiting activity is clearly popular with customers.

But other theories exist about the peanuts! One idea suggests they serve as a warning for people with allergies. Five Guys fries are cooked only in peanut oil. Boxes of this oil are often nearby. The peanuts are a very clear warning, you might say. Another theory thinks shelling peanuts keeps people occupied. It stops them from watching the busy kitchen. Instead, they focus on eating their snack.

9. **The Great Milkshake Debate: Adding Them Was a Big Deal!**: Most people think a fast-food menu should include milkshakes. They seem like a natural complement to burgers. A sweet, creamy shake balances the meal. Adding milkshakes seemed like an obvious and simple choice for Five Guys. However, adding milkshakes was a significant decision. It required a lot of convincing, especially for Jerry Murrell.

Jerry really didn’t want to add more items to the menu. He had previously tried adding coffee. A chicken sandwich was another attempt. He said he considered both of these “disasters.” This made him hesitant to add something new. He feared failing again or diluting the brand’s concept. But a dedicated owner, Tom Horton, loved milkshakes. He kept urging the Murrell family to add them.

Tom Horton’s efforts eventually paid off! Five Guys finally added milkshakes in 2014. Initially, they offered just a vanilla base. But in true Five Guys style, they provided a variety of mix-ins. Customers could then customize their shakes. They could add bananas or salted caramel. Even crispy bacon bits were an option! This allowed for creative shakes, like an Elvis tribute with peanut butter and bacon, or a classic Oreo shake. Fans say they easily outshine other places’ shakes. Adding milkshakes truly completed their menu.

10. **The Secret Behind Those Squishy Buns**: If you eat at Five Guys often, you’re familiar with their buns. You’ll notice that they are very soft and squishy. Some people might prefer a firmer bun. But this texture choice was made on purpose. It carries a bit of history for Five Guys. These soft buns are different from regular ones. They can also get messy with a juicy burger, making eating a wonderfully messy experience.

The origin of these special buns dates back a long way. The first store in Virginia bought buns locally from a bakery called Brenner’s in Alexandria. These were special, sweeter, eggier rolls that really enhanced the taste of the first burger. They weren’t your typical store-bought buns. When Brenner’s closed, Five Guys hired bakers to replicate the rolls themselves, in order to maintain their signature style.

Five Guys grew rapidly. The demand for these buns became too great. They couldn’t produce enough buns within the company. This led to missed deliveries. To meet the demand, they hired outside bakers but ensured they replicated the original style. The commitment to this bun recipe is evident. Even if it makes eating a bit messy, it adds to the fun, delicious experience of Five Guys.

11. **The Mysterious Case of the Exclusive Mayonnaise**: People have strong feelings about mayonnaise. They might even argue about their favorite brands. The rivalry between Hellman’s and Duke’s, for example, is well-known. Five Guys also takes its mayonnaise choices seriously. So seriously, in fact, that they tested many different kinds. This was to ensure that it met their standards.

Reports about Five Guys’ operations behind the scenes share some details. The people responsible for choosing the mayonnaise did not take the task lightly. They conducted a blind taste test. Reportedly, they tasted sixteen different mayonnaises. Finally, they selected a specific Heinz blend. This blend is used in all Five Guys locations. It is not the regular Heinz mayonnaise found in stores. It is a special blend made exclusively for them.

This special Heinz mayonnaise blend has a unique taste. People describe it as being richer than normal mayonnaise. It has a slight tang that you might notice. But it also has a mellow flavor. The goal is to complement the burgers and not clash with all the toppings. The interesting thing is that you cannot buy this mayonnaise anywhere outside of Five Guys stores. If you like their mayonnaise, you must get it there. Your only option is to order food with it.

And that’s the story about Five Guys! We delved deep into their world for you. All the way to fascinating secrets about the chain. We explored the smart reason behind offering free peanuts. The history of not offering delivery for years. The story behind the family name was told. Adding milkshakes was also a journey.

We talked about the intentional softness of the buns. The high number of calories in their famous fries. And even the very secret and unique mayonnaise blend they use. It is clear that Five Guys is more than just food. It is an experience built on specific choices.

Sometimes these choices are a bit quirky, you see. This has built a passionate fanbase that they have. Discovering these details makes visiting more fun. So next time you’re there eating peanuts, waiting for that big overflowing bag of food, you’ll know a little more about what makes Five Guys special.

Related posts:
Forget The Classic Burger – Five Guys’ Melty Secret Menu Item Will Change The Way You Order
Five Guys employee reveals ‘secret hack’ when ordering and fans urge chain to ‘put it on the menu’
11 Restaurant Chains That Serve the Best Secret Menu Items