For any burger enthusiast, Five Guys is the epitome of comfort food bliss. Hand-formed, meaty burgers, crispy fries cooked in peanut oil – the experience is already legendary. Yet, behind the scenes, there exists a world of secret menu items that have been developed by fans and insiders to take your order to new, truly unprecedented heights. Five Guys secret menu is not merely a catalog of add-ins it’s an arena where excess, imagination, and flavour collide.
These secret menu items are more than simple tweaks like adding another patty or swapping a sauce. They are inventive, fan-engineered creations that transform familiar favorites into gourmet-like experiences. From towering burger sandwiches to spicy fries and even savory-sweet milkshakes, these hacks allow for unlimited experimentation. Each visit can be a unique adventure, whether you’re chasing new textures, bold flavors, or simply the satisfaction of being an insider.
Whether you’re a longtime Five Guys regular or a newcomer eager to explore, understanding the secret menu unlocks a new dimension of dining. These hacks allow for both indulgent treats and creative customizations, catering to adventurous eaters, health-conscious fans, and anyone in between. This guide breaks down fifteen of the most exciting secret menu items, offering tips on how to order them and what to expect with every bite.
1. Cheese Fries
Leading off our list is a favorite: the Cheese Fries. Five Guys’ already-well-liked fries crispy on the outside and fluffy on the inside are made into something truly amazing when covered in melted, warm cheese. This extra step takes an otherwise side item to a decadent, gooey treat that will best any other fast-food cheese fries in town.
For all cheese lovers, this is a revelation. The melting cheese and the crunchy salty fries is an indulgent and addictive one. It is easy to order just ask for “Cheese Fries.” There may be a small fee at some, but it is worth paying a small price for a huge flavor reward. The Cheese Fries are a great introduction to the universe of Five Guys secret menu offerings, bringing comfort and creativity.
- Cheese Fries can be enjoyed as a side or the main feature.
- Show the creativity and appeal of secret menu hacks.
- Comforting, versatile, and consistently satisfying.
- Capture the indulgent spirit that helped make Five Guys popular.
2. Patty Melt
The Patty Melt is an upscale rendition of an old favorite sandwich. Ground beef patty is capped with melted cheese, along with sweet, caramelized grilled onions, and served on two slices of grilled, buttered pieces of bread. The outcome is a soothing but refined flavor experience that makes each bite unforgettable.
Five Guys gives this diner classic a distinctive twist by employing its signature inside-out hamburger buns and melting Kraft American cheese to create a gooey center and crunchy exterior. This diversity creates a richness and degree of ease of access of texture perfectly suited for die-hard enthusiasts who are looking for the comfort of familiarity with a turn.
- Customisation is central to creating this secret menu item.
- Add extra toppings or patties according to your preference.
- Order a grilled cheese and request any additional ingredients you like.
- Staff are generally accommodating, making it a convenient and satisfying option.
3. Well-Done Fries
For an added crunch, the Well-Done Fries offer a crispy golden brown outside that puts a new spin on the humble French fry. The fries are cooked for longer than most, providing an amazing textural bite with every bite since they still retain a fluffy center.
This hack is ideal for fry lovers who love texture diversity. Although some of the shops might resist doing them due to the fact that they take extra cooking time, the outcome is worth it.
- Pair the fries with your favourite burger or dipping sauce for extra indulgence.
- Adds a new layer of richness and depth to the meal.
- Appeals to those who value texture as much as flavour.
- Elevates a simple side into a more decadent experience.
4. Double Grilled Cheeseburger
Double Grilled Cheeseburger is the indulgence supreme. In place of a standard bun, this behemoth employs two grilled cheese sandwiches to contain your burger patties and toppings. The melding is incredible, indulgent, and satisfying in a distinct manner.
This invention is ideal for beef and cheese lovers. With each bite, it gives you a combination of melted cheese, flavorful beef, and buttery toasted bread, giving you an intense and complex flavor and texture experience. You can also personalize the number of patties and complimentary toppings according to your appetite.
- Caution: the portion size is huge, even for experienced diners.
- Made by placing burger toppings between two grilled cheese sandwiches.
- Delivers a spicy, playful twist on the standard menu.
- Showcases Five Guys’ openness and flexibility toward customisation.
5. Bacon Milkshake
Five Guys shakes are a dessert in their own right, but bacon on a vanilla foundation is a sweet-savory treat. Applewood-smoked bacon crumbles add a great crunch and unexpected richness of flavor to accompany the rich shake.
To make it an even richer indulgence, enthusiasts sometimes top it with chocolate, peanut butter, or additional peanuts. The result is a protein-rich, guilty milkshake with sweet and salty in every sip.
- Easy to order: request a milkshake with bacon and extra mix-ins like chocolate or peanut butter.
- Turns a classic shake into a fun, savoury-sweet treat.
- Highlights Five Guys’ playful approach to customisation.
- Shows that creativity at the chain extends beyond burgers and fries to desserts.
6. Lettuce-Wrapped Burger / Burger Bowl
The ketogenic or low-carb dieter will appreciate the flowery taste without the bun. The leaf lettuce wraps the patty, and any toppings can be added.
This accommodates customers to relish Five Guys’ celebrated juicy burger patties without sacrificing diet. Cheeseburgers are a favorite among collectors for the extra taste, excluding carb-loaded condiments such as ketchup.
- Simple to order: ask for a hot bacon burger wrapped or in a bowl with toppings.
- Shows how small adjustments can reshape the dining experience.
- Appeals to health-conscious consumers without losing flavour.
- Demonstrates the flexibility of Five Guys’ menu for different lifestyles.
7. The Presidential Burger
For President Barack Obama’s 2009 visit, the Presidential Burger is a cheeseburger topped with lettuce, tomatoes, jalapeños, and mustard. The crisp freshness, a touch of spice, and zesty zip all come together to create a tasty, unforgettable burger.
To order, merely refer to each topping by name rather than the name. The Presidential Burger is a nice flashback to days past and a pleasant way to consume a product of the proper dimensions. It’s an observation about Five Guys’ build-your-own philosophy, making even a modest visit a unique experience.
- Ordering requires naming each topping individually rather than using a set name.
- The Presidential Burger offers a nostalgic nod to past favourites.
- Provides a properly sized, balanced option that feels classic.
- Reflects Five Guys’ build-your-own philosophy, making every visit unique.
8. Nacho-Style Fries
Nacho-Style Fries elevate the simple fries to a fiesta level of flavor. Fries are loaded with melted cheese, bacon, and jalapeños, mirroring the popularity of loaded nachos. The mixture results in a spicy, savory, and full-bodied snack.
There is an optional cheese charge, but the flavor dividend is worth it. Simply ask for “fries with melted cheese, bacon, and jalapeños” for this off-menu dish. It’s perfect for those who like bold, layered tastes.
- Comes with an optional cheese charge, but the taste justifies it.
- Order by requesting “fries with melted cheese, bacon, and jalapeños.”
- An off-menu option that feels indulgent and satisfying.
- Ideal for anyone who enjoys bold, layered flavours.
9. Breaking Windy City Dog
Five Guys’ secret menu also includes hot dogs such as the Breaking Windy City Dog. It is a Chicago-style dog topped with tomatoes, pickles, relish, green peppers, mustard, hot sauce, and Cajun seasoning.
Each topping is ordered separately. The end result is a spicy hot dog full of flavor and departure from the standard menu but is readily accessible to adventurous eaters to try. It’s an old standby flipped around.
- Requires ordering each topping separately to build the dish.
- Creates a spicy, flavour-packed hot dog that stands out from the usual menu.
- Appeals to adventurous eaters seeking something different yet accessible.
- Reinvents a classic standby with a fun, unexpected twist.
10. Steak Frites
Steak Frites hack introduces bistro style to Five Guys. A burger topped with A.1. sauce, without a bun, approximates steak taste, accompanied by fries on the side. Coated generously with salt and pepper, it’s a surprisingly elegant meal.
Wine isn’t necessary but does enhance the meal. Steak Frites shows that Five Guys ingredients can replicate gourmet taste at fast-food speed.
- Wine is optional but elevates the overall dining experience.
- Steak Frites demonstrates how Five Guys’ ingredients can feel gourmet.
- Combines high-end flavour with the quick service of fast food.
- Proves that creativity can transform familiar items into an upscale dish.
11. Animal Style-Inspired Burgers and Fries
In-N-Out’s “Animal Style” enthusiasts can replicate the experience with Five Guys’ toppings. Extra cheese, caramelized onions, tomato, and pickles provide an abundance of flavor. Cheese and onion top fries, and a do-it-yourself special sauce comprised of relish, ketchup, and mayo completes the experience.
This hack showcases the creativity and individuality that allow supporters to mix favorite aspects of multiple chains. Including the interactive element of mixing your sauce makes the dish personal.
- Highlights creativity and individuality in food choices across chains.
- Lets fans combine favourite elements from different menus for a unique twist.
- The interactive sauce-mixing element adds fun and personalisation.
- Turns a simple meal into a custom experience tailored to individual taste.
12. Vegetarian BLT
The Vegetarian BLT substitutes the bacon with grilled mushrooms but retains the standard lettuce, tomato, and optional cheese. Jalapeños can be added for crunch and heat, offering a meat-free option that is savory.
It’s a resourceful application of Five Guys’ components to turn into a filling veggie choice. The off-menu option proves that vegetarians can even have creative fare at the chain.
- Shows Five Guys’ flexibility beyond the standard burger-and-fries reputation.
- Proves that customisation allows diners to create meals tailored to their taste.
- Offers vegetarians a filling, satisfying alternative without compromising flavour.
- Makes the fast-food experience more inclusive and enjoyable for different diets.
13. Jalapeño Popper Sandwich
The Jalapeño Popper Sandwich takes a grilled cheese and turns it into a cheesy, spicy treat. Additional cheese, bacon, and sliced jalapeños turn it into a decadent experience similar to the popular appetizer but in handheld form.
Combining with a vanilla milkshake neutralizes the heat, and the bacon contributes depth of texture. It’s a taste-bud-ahead, spicy play for enthusiasts who appreciate innovative and spicy food on their plate.
- Pairing with a vanilla milkshake balances the heat
- Bacon adds richness and texture to the mix
- Creates a bold, spicy option for adventurous eaters
- Appeals to those who enjoy innovative food combinations
14. The Artery Annihilator
The ultimate dish features a bacon cheeseburger stacked atop a split hot dog to form a meat tower. Toppings, mayonnaise, and barbecue sauce add richness, excess, and protein.
It’s a test for bold eaters, the ultimate manifestation of Five Guys’ freedom of choice. Not for the faint of heart, it’s an indication of the way the secret menu expands the culinary frontier.
- Appeals to adventurous eaters seeking unique experiences
- Highlights Five Guys’ openness to experimentation with food
- Maintains quality while expanding beyond the ordinary
- Celebrates individuality and playful dining choices
15. Sloppy Joe
Recreating the quintessential homemade Sloppy Joe, this hack employs a burger that is topped with grilled green peppers, onions, ketchup, and barbecue sauce. The mix mimics the quintessential sweet-savory flavor profile of the legendary sandwich.
- Retro twist: turns a plain burger into a nostalgic classic
- Creative method: inventive yet simple approach to elevate a staple
- Respect for tradition: Five Guys balances creativity with honoring food heritage
From stringy cheese fries to beefy meat stacks, the secret menu at Five Guys is a goldmine of innovative options. Every concoction showcases the brand’s dedication to customization and customer innovation. Whatever your appetites trendy staples, creative flavors, or clever hacks the secret menu makes every trip a customized experience. Branch out, order in, and enjoy each morsel of these off-menu gems.
