The U.S. “President’s Club,” an exclusive fellowship of living presidents, holds a special place in American politics, currently boasting six members, including Joe Biden, who have all shouldered the immense weight of the nation’s highest office.
This shared, almost incomprehensible experience cultivates a profound bond, often uniting individuals who, by all political standards, would appear to be the unlikeliest of allies, with a unique camaraderie emerging post-presidency that defies typical political rivalries.
While the public often envisions former presidents as distant, even stuffy figures, engaged in formal poses and deep thoughts, the reality of their interactions can be far more personal and surprisingly warm. The journey from bitter political foes to trusted confidantes or collaborative partners highlights a fascinating dynamic at the highest echelons of American power, revealing a depth of relationship that extends far beyond the headlines.
1.The primary reason for these surprising friendships among former U.S. presidents stems from the uniquely isolating nature of the presidency itself, where only those who have occupied the Oval Office can truly comprehend its immense pressures, responsibilities, and profound solitude, forging an exclusive connection that transcends partisan politics and ideological differences.
This unique understanding is so potent that, as the text notes, “They share an experience that no one else can understand, and that brings together even the unlikeliest of people.” The weight of leading a nation, making life-or-death decisions, and being constantly under scrutiny instills a mutual respect and empathy that can soften even the most deeply embedded political hostilities.
Once out of office, the competitive political arena fades, allowing a common identity as former commanders-in-chief to take precedence. The often-bitter rhetoric of Democrat-versus-Republican can truly “melt in the presidents club,” paving the way for former rivals to become “unlikely mates.” This shared journey through the crucible of the presidency forms an unbreakable tie, irrespective of how fiercely they once campaigned against each other.
2. **Post-Office Practicalities Forging Bonds**Beyond the abstract shared experience, concrete practicalities of post-presidency life also serve as unexpected catalysts for bonding among former leaders. One particularly illustrative example comes from the unlikely friendship between Jimmy Carter and Gerald Ford, a Democrat and Republican who had once battled fiercely for the presidency.
Their intensely personal friendship, described by two historians as arguably the most personal between any two presidents, began in 1981. It started when Ronald Reagan dispatched both men to represent the U.S. at the funeral of Anwar Sadat, the assassinated Egyptian leader. During this trip, a somewhat awkward Richard Nixon was also present, yet it was Carter and Ford who truly connected.
They discovered common ground not in grand political strategies, but in the surprisingly mundane yet personally significant challenges that arise after leaving the White House, such as the difficulties of raising funds for presidential libraries, which highlighted how shared, practical post-presidency struggles can foster unexpected camaraderie.
3. **Bipartisan Humanitarian & Diplomatic Missions**A significant factor in the forging of relationships among former presidents is their continued involvement in high-stakes bipartisan humanitarian and diplomatic missions at the behest of current administrations. Leveraging their public stature, deep relationships with foreign leaders, and unique expertise, these former chief executives often undertake critical work that benefits their successors, regardless of party affiliation.
Jimmy Carter, despite his sometimes challenging nature, exemplified this role by achieving “significant results at times, thanks to his public stature as a peacemaker, humanitarian and champion of democracy and his deep relationships with foreign leaders, troublemakers included.” For instance, in 1994, he averted a U.S. invasion of Haiti, brokering a deal for the military coup leader to step aside and restore democracy, directly benefiting Democratic President Bill Clinton and saving countless lives. This was undeniably a significant win, demonstrating the power of a former president’s diplomatic engagement.
Four years earlier, Carter similarly secured peace in Nicaragua for Republican President George H.W. Bush. At the brink of bloodshed, Carter persuaded leftist leader Daniel Ortega to accept an electoral defeat that had shocked the Sandinistas. These missions, often undertaken in tandem or with support from their successors, create a professional interdependence that frequently evolves into mutual respect and, eventually, personal connection, as they navigate complex global challenges together for the national interest.
4. **Overcoming Rivalry for the Greater Good**One of the most compelling aspects of the “Presidents Club” is its capacity to transform bitter political rivals into close collaborators, driven by a sense of shared responsibility for the nation and global welfare. The extraordinary 14-year friendship between former President George H.W. Bush and Bill Clinton, who defeated Bush in the 1992 election, stands as a prime example of this phenomenon.
Their close bond blossomed following a period of intense rivalry, significantly aided by George W. Bush, who enlisted them to lead a fundraising mission for countries devastated by the 2004 Indian Ocean earthquake and tsunami. Working together, Clinton and the elder Bush embarked on a four-day tour of the region and subsequently helped raise substantial funds for continued relief efforts back in the U.S. This shared, crucial humanitarian endeavor necessitated setting aside any “lingering hard feelings for the sake of a bigger cause,” and the experience proved transformative for their relationship.
This collaborative spirit was not entirely unprecedented, as the Clintons had visited the Bushes in Kennebunkport, Maine, in the early 1980s, before their political paths diverged so sharply. However, it was their post-presidency work together that solidified a deep, lasting connection, with George W. Bush even playfully remarking that his own father was among Clinton’s “loved ones.” This demonstrates a powerful ability to transcend past electoral battles when united by a common, benevolent purpose.
5. **Seeking and Offering Counsel**The tradition of presidents, both sitting and former, seeking and offering counsel forms a vital artery of continuity and wisdom within the “Presidents Club.” The unique insights gleaned from holding the highest office are considered indispensable, often leading successors to tap into the wellspring of experience provided by their predecessors. This exchange of advice frequently deepens professional respect into personal trust and friendship.
Democrat Lyndon Johnson, for instance, found significant support in his Republican predecessor, Dwight Eisenhower, even seeking his counsel on addressing Congress after John Kennedy’s assassination, which underscores the deep reliance presidents place on the unique understanding only another former president can offer during times of crisis.
Similarly, Bill Clinton cherished his “long and frequent phone calls with Richard Nixon,” confiding in the “disgraced but savvy Republican on foreign policy problems of the era.” More recently, President Biden consulted with former Presidents Obama and George W. Bush ahead of his decision to withdraw troops from Afghanistan, illustrating that for Biden, the “advice and support of past presidents is ‘grounding’ and indispensable.” This consistent pattern of seeking and providing guidance underscores the enduring and crucial nature of these inter-presidential bonds.
Beyond the initial practicalities and shared burdens of the presidency, deeper personal connections often emerge, weaving a rich tapestry of relationships within the “Presidents Club.” These bonds are forged not just through official duties but also through shared life experiences, the subtle dynamics of group interactions, and moments of profound personal support. Let’s delve into these more intimate aspects that further solidify the surprising friendships among those who have held the nation’s highest office.
6. **Personal Kinship and Shared Life Details**The enduring and deeply personal friendship between Jimmy Carter and Gerald Ford stands as a testament to how shared life details, extending beyond politics, can forge an unbreakable bond. Their relationship, which blossomed after Ford’s presidency, became a genuine “buddy movie,” marked by their mutual enjoyment of each other’s company on road trips that, to them, were never quite long enough because they had so much to discuss.
This connection wasn’t merely superficial; it was rooted in commonalities that ran deeper than their political affiliations. Both men were Navy veterans, shared the experience of raising three sons, and possessed a strong religious faith—though Ford was noted to be quieter about his. Crucially, their spouses also developed a close bond, with Carter eloquently stating, “The four of us learned to love each other.” This shared family dynamic cemented a friendship that truly spanned generations and partisan divides.
Their closeness extended to active teamwork, with Carter and Ford frequently collaborating on numerous projects and even coordinating their attendance at public events, demonstrating a level of mutual respect rarely seen between political rivals, with Carter fondly recalling their shared private moments as something they ‘hated to reach our destination’ from.
7. **The Paradoxical Bonding Over a Difficult Member**Curiously, shared exasperation with a particular member can sometimes unite the other “insiders” within the Presidents Club, creating an unexpected form of solidarity. Jimmy Carter, despite his invaluable contributions to his successors, often found himself in this unique position. His distinct personality and approach sometimes fostered a collective, albeit sometimes begrudging, bond among the other former presidents.
As Nancy Gibbs and Michael Duffy noted in their book “The Presidents Club,” “The others often bonded over ‘what an annoying cuss Carter could be.'” He was described as “the driven, self-righteous, impatient perfectionist who united the other club members around what seemed like an eternal question: was Jimmy Carter worth the trouble?” This shared dynamic, however challenging, created a common ground for others to relate to and discuss.
Carter’s self-assured declarations of superiority and his occasional independent actions, like lobbying against George H.W. Bush’s Gulf War efforts or engaging in unauthorized negotiations, set him apart, a visual metaphor captured in a 2009 photo where he stands “conspicuously off to the side” from other presidents, illustrating his unique, somewhat isolated, yet paradoxically unifying role.
This phenomenon isn’t exclusive to Carter. Donald Trump, too, became an figure over whom other club members, regardless of party, expressed disdain during his first term, and he, in turn, “had no use for them.” This highlights how the presence of a truly disruptive or unconventional figure can, in an ironic twist, solidify the bonds and shared identity of the more established members of this exclusive fraternity, reinforcing their collective understanding of the office and its conventions.
8. **Unexpected Personal Chemistry**Beyond shared experiences and political collaborations, sometimes simple, unexpected personal chemistry sparks surprising friendships across political divides, proving that human connection can indeed transcend partisan lines. These are the moments born from informal interactions, shared jokes, or poignant shared events, creating bonds that captivate public attention.
One of the most heartwarming examples is the good-natured relationship between George W. Bush and Michelle Obama. Bush playfully suggested to Jimmy Kimmel that their friendship began from “sitting together at so many funerals,” where she became a fan of his “quiet jokes” during lengthy eulogies. Their public hug at the 2016 opening of the National Museum of African American History and Culture went viral, surprising a nation accustomed to political polarization.
Bush himself reflected on this, telling “CBS Sunday Morning” that he believes it’s problematic that “Americans are so polarized in their thinking that they can’t imagine a George W. Bush and a Michelle Obama being friends.” This chemistry extends to Bill Clinton and the elder George Bush, whose relationship blossomed into deep affection. After their post-tsunami relief work, they enjoyed golf, “zippy boat rides,” and “nights by the sea” in Kennebunkport, Maine, solidifying a bond so strong that Clinton declared, “I just loved him” upon Bush’s death in 2018. Such instances demonstrate how genuine personal rapport can flourish even after intense political battles.
9.The “Presidents Club” also functions as an invaluable informal institution, providing direct political instruction and mentorship to successors, guiding them through the ceremonial, practical, and strategic complexities of the presidency, which goes far beyond simple advice to encompass the nuanced art of presidential conduct.
An illuminating example of this practical mentorship comes from Ronald Reagan, who, during the campaign, noticed Bill Clinton’s “lame” military salute. Reagan, ever the seasoned performer, pulled Clinton aside to offer a personal lesson, teaching him how to execute a “snappy” salute fit for the commander-in-chief. This was not a policy discussion, but a direct instruction on the decorum and symbolic weight of the office.
Furthermore, the guidance often extends to high-level strategic counsel. Bill Clinton deeply valued his “long and frequent phone calls with Richard Nixon,” often confiding in the “disgraced but savvy Republican on foreign policy problems of the era.” Nixon, despite his past, possessed an undeniable strategic mind and deep understanding of international relations, making his insights invaluable to a sitting president grappling with global complexities. These exchanges highlight how even those who have left office under a cloud can still offer profound political instruction.
President Biden’s recent consultations with former Presidents Obama and George W. Bush regarding the Afghanistan troop withdrawal exemplify this tradition of seeking seasoned strategic input, framing these discussions as a form of high-level political instruction that grounds current decisions in the profound understanding of the office’s burdens gained from past experiences.
10. **Providing Personal Support During Adversity**Perhaps the most poignant aspect of the “Presidents Club” is its profound role in offering critical personal support during times of immense adversity, tragedy, or challenge. Only those who have faced the unique pressures of the presidency can truly comprehend the personal toll, making their comfort and counsel indispensable.
Barack Obama’s unwavering support for Joe Biden during the illness and tragic death of his son, Beau, stands as a powerful testament to this. Obama not only offered financial assistance to help with medical bills but also delivered the eulogy at Beau’s funeral, providing deeply personal comfort and solidarity during an unimaginably difficult period. This act of profound empathy showcased a bond that transcended their professional relationship, solidifying their friendship beyond the political stage.
Similarly, on the night of John Kennedy’s assassination, Democrat Lyndon Johnson found himself in an unforeseen and overwhelming crisis. He immediately reached out to his Republican predecessor, Dwight Eisenhower, confessing, “I need you more than ever now.” This plea for guidance and emotional support during the nation’s darkest hour highlights the unique psychological and practical support network that only former presidents can provide to one another. The shared burden of leading a grieving nation forged an immediate, intense bond of understanding.
Even in anticipation of personal adversity, these bonds hold sway. The singular friendship between Jimmy Carter and Gerald Ford included a heartfelt pact, almost unimaginable in today’s fiercely partisan climate: “Whoever died first would be eulogized by the other.” This solemn agreement, shared by two men from opposing parties who once battled for the White House, speaks volumes about the depth of their personal connection and their commitment to supporting each other, even in their ultimate farewells.
More than just a group of influential figures, the “Presidents Club” is a remarkable and often surprising fraternity, where relationships built on shared burdens, practical cooperation, genuine connection, or profound personal support reveal a fascinating dynamic at the core of American democracy, proving that human connection and mutual respect can indeed flourish across political divides.
