The Unveiled Secret: Why Professional Chefs Demand This Specific Steak Thickness at the Butcher

There’s just something about the sizzle of a steak as it hits that scorching hot cast-iron pan, and the aroma of rich, meaty goodness wafting through the kitchen-it automatically makes one feel like a true culinary rockstar. But I learned the hard way-after serving up one too many dry, chewy steaks at a family barbecue-that the real secret to a juicy, perfectly crusted masterpiece isn’t just in the seasoning or heat; it’s in the thickness of your steak. For example, my very first foray into a fancy steak dinner went completely south-those thin cuts from the supermarket were Gray and tough before I could even say, “medium-rare.”

Chefs and pitmasters swear by 1.5 inches of thickness, and let me tell you-it will change the game for every home cook who wishes for that restaurant-quality bite. It is not about getting a bigger portion but controlling that heat to bring in a steak crispy on the outside and juicy on the inside every single time. Why is thickness so important? It’s in how the heat dances with the meat, finding a perfect balance between a Savory, caramelized crust and a succulent, pink interior that makes your taste buds sing.

If it’s too thin, a steak cooks too fast and dries out before it can even get a nice crisp on it; if it’s too thick, the risk is that it’ll burn on the outside before it’s cooked through. I used to think just a quick sear and some salt did the trick. Of course, that was until I ruined a batch at a friend’s cookout, and then I knew that magic starts at the cut. In this blog, we take a deep dive into why 1.5 inches is the gold standard, how to handle different thickness levels, and a few tricks to avoid common steak-cooking disasters. Grab your tongs, light the grill, and let’s unlock the secrets of a steak so good it will absolutely steal the show at your next dinner party.

1. Why 1.5 Inches Is the Gold Standard

Every chef with whom I have spoken-from the backyard grill enthusiasts all the way up to the Michelin-star pros-says that 1.5 inches or about 3.8 cm is that sweet spot right in the middle of perfection. It’s not some arbitrary figure they pull out of the air but rather an ideal size that balances control over doneness with the development of that drool-worthy, caramelized crust that makes a steak unforgettable. I learned that one the hard way, at a summer barbecue when my bargain-bin thin steaks became hockey pucks before I could even flip them properly.

But behind that magic number lies some interesting science, based on some pretty solid principles about how heat interacts with meat. When you sear a steak, you are chasing the Maillard reaction-that chemical wizardry which browns the surface and creates rich, Savory Flavors that make your mouth water at just the very thought. A 1.5-inch steak has the perfect mass to let this reaction develop fully without the heat racing through too quickly or dawdling too long. Anything thinner, and the centre overcooks before the crust can form; anything thicker, and you get a raw middle or a charred exterior.

• Balances even cooking with flavourful crust.
• Enough mass not to overcook the interior.
• Perfect for cuts of ribeye, strip, or filet mignon.
• Tightly sealed; provides exact doneness levels.
• Improves texture, provides a juicy, tender centre.

That all changed with a steak that was 1.5 inches thick. I remember the first time, at my friend’s dinner party, cutting into one and hearing that crust crackle open to reveal the pink, juicy interior; it was like I had unlocked some sort of gastronomic secret. It was of the perfect thickness, and well, it just made me feel so professional. Now, I have my butcher cut them all that size. Ditch those flimsy supermarket cuts and make the switch to 1.5 inches-you’ll be wondering how you ever settled for less.

Get this recipe >>

2. The Trouble with Thin Steaks

Thin steaks are the siren song of supermarket meat counters: cheap, plentiful, and oh-so-tempting for a quick dinner. But I once fell for their budget-friendly trap, thinking I was getting a deal, only to serve up leathery, overcooked bites that no amount of sauce could save. The problem is pretty simple: heat blasts through thin cuts so fast that by the time you get a decent sear, the inside’s already well done, and instead of yielding a juicy masterpiece, you get a dry, chewy mess.

Thin steaks have none of that mass to give you the time the Maillard reaction needs to take place and give your steak some flavour. You couldn’t have a crunchy crust while retaining a tender, pink interior. I learned this the hard way when what was supposed to be a quick steak dinner with friends turned into serving tough, flavourless slabs. Thin cuts dry out fast, and they don’t leave much room for error when it comes to timing.

• Overcook before developing a proper crust.
• Dry out quickly, losing juiciness and flavour.
• Quality sacrificed – Common in budget cuts
• Hard to achieve medium-rare without charring.
• No mass to support complex flavour profiles.

Thin steaks quickly taught me that less is often more. After one too many chewy disasters, I started to always choose cuts of steak that were thicker, when available. The difference was like night and day. You can try high heat and fast cooking when you are working with an invariably thin cut of meat, but for the best results, bypass the bargain bin and invest in a 1.5-inch steak that delivers the juicy, flavourful experience you’re after.

Air Fryer Steak with Garlic Herb Butter

Yes, you can even cook steak in an air fryer! We found that thicker cuts, like sirloin, are best — they turn nice and browned on the outside without overcooking. Plus, there’s very little clean up. We added a homemade garlic-herb butter to melt over the steak for a quick and flavorful weeknight dinner.

Print Recipe Pin Recipe

Cook Time 10 minutes mins

Total Time 30 minutes mins

Course lunch/dinner

Cuisine American

Servings 2 people

Calories 3877.9 kcal

Equipment

• 1 Air Fryer 3.5-quart or larger
• 1 Cutting Board
• 1 Small Mixing Bowl
• 1 Knife Chef’s knife for slicing and chopping
• 1 Microplane or Garlic Grater For finely grating garlic

Ingredients

  

Main

• One 1-pound sirloin steak about 1 inch thick
• Kosher salt and freshly ground black pepper
• 4 tablespoons unsalted butter at room temperature
• 1 tablespoon finely chopped fresh parsley
• 1 tablespoon finely chopped fresh chives
• 1 small clove garlic finely grated
• 1/4 teaspoon crushed red pepper flakes

Instructions

 

• Allow the steak to sit at room temperature for 30 minutes before cooking.
• Preheat a 3.5-quart air fryer to 400 degrees F. Season the steak on both sides with a generous pinch of salt and several grinds of black pepper. Place the steak in the center of the air fryer basket and cook until desired doneness, about 10 minutes for medium-rare, 12 minutes for medium and 14 minutes for medium-well. Transfer the steak to a cutting board and allow to rest, about 10 minutes.
• Meanwhile, mash together the butter, parsley, chives, garlic and crushed red pepper in a small bowl until combined. Slice the steak against the grain into 1/4-inch-thick pieces. Top with the garlic-herb butter.

Notes

Ensuring the steak comes to room temperature before cooking is crucial for even cooking and a tender result. Patting the steak dry before seasoning can aid in achieving a better sear. Utilize a meat thermometer for precise doneness, targeting 130-135°F (54-57°C) for medium-rare, as air fryer temperatures can vary. Resting the cooked steak is non-negotiable; it allows juices to redistribute, ensuring a tender and flavorful bite. The garlic-herb butter is a fantastic finishing touch, adding richness and aromatic complexity; consider a touch of lemon zest for brightness if desired.

Get this recipe >>

3. The Challenges of Extra-Thick Steaks

Thick steaks-2 inches or more-sound like the ultimate carnivore fantasy: hearty, substantial, and juicy. But they can be an absolute beast to cook if one doesn’t come into the situation with the right mindset or approach. Once, I got cocky and bought this huge ribeye, thinking that bigger is always better. After wrestling it around on the grill for what felt like an eternity, I ended up with a charred exterior and a raw middle. Because it takes so long to reach the core, the surface can burn, leaving you with a thick ring of overcooked meat surrounding a tiny, perfectly cooked middle. It’s a frustrating textural rollercoaster, one that makes even an expensive cut of meat feel like a waste.

These thick cuts really call for expert methods, like two-zone grilling or reverse searing, so you can avoid that disaster of a burnt outside and raw inside. I have watched the chefs pick up the 3-inch monster and give it a nice, gentle low-heat cook until time came for the quick sear, and I realized: thick steaks demand delicacy, not crudeness. The longer it cooks, the higher the chances are of burning the outside, and you easily lose that tender and juicy quality which makes steak great.

• Risk burning the outside before the centre cooks.
• Can develop an overcooked ring around the middle.
• Require advanced techniques like reverse searing.
• Longer cooking times increase error margin.
• Expensive for potentially uneven results.

Thick steaks are a bold choice, but they really taught me respect for technique over ambition. After my ribeye disaster, I tried reverse searing, and it turned out to be a revelation: juicy even and delicious from edge to edge. If drama at the steakhouse is what you want, go ahead-but go armed with the right methods. Otherwise, 1.5 inches is where you want to be when it comes to the foolproof path to steak perfection.

4. Evenness: The unsung hero of steak cooking

Get the thickness just right at 1.5 inches, but that uneven steak can undo your work in the time it takes to say “overcooked.” I learned that the hard way once by taking home a cheaper cut that was thick across the middle and tapered around the edges; it looked like two steaks in one-the thin parts well done, the middle barely rare. “Your steak’s thickness should be as uniform as possible,” Chef Chris Frothingham told Real Simple. Poorly cut steaks mess with heat distribution; the result of that is a plate full of different textures and Flavors, unsatisfying on the whole.

Another sneaky culprit: thick bands of exterior fat. As they shrink more quickly than the meat itself, the steak curls up like a taco. I managed to make this mistake once; my steak popped off the pan and wrecked what would have been a beautiful sear, leaving a lopsided mess. The solution is simple: score the fat band before cooking, which helps it render evenly and keeps the steak flat. “You get what you pay for,” says Frothingham. A cheap, uneven cut won’t cook consistently throughout the steak.

• prevents thin areas from overcooking.
• Scoring the fat bands stops curling and uneven searing.
• Avoids budget cuts due to inconsistent thickness.
• Ensures flavour and texture consistency.

Uniformity took my steak game from hit-or-miss to a sure thing. I will never forget that first slice into a perfectly even strip steak, juicy and tender with each bit like the last-it felt like some kind of chef’s code had been cracked. Make sure to check with the butcher for consistent thickness, or have them give it a trim; it’s one of those little steps that makes all the difference toward a wowing steak.

Get this recipe >>

5. The Perfect 1.5 Inch Steak

Grilling a 1.5-inch steak is like conducting a symphony-you got to get the rhythm right if you’re going to hit all the right notes. Preheat your grill or cast-iron pan screaming hot, and season liberally with coarse salt, about 1 teaspoon per pound, for that crunchy, Savory crust. I learned early to pat my steak dry after a soggy sear killed my crust once; moisture is the enemy of the Maillard reaction. Take the steak out and let it sit at room temperature for 30 minutes; this has helped even out the cooking, and it’s one of those things I wish I had known when I first started grilling.

A meat thermometer is your best friend when trying to nail the doneness-for medium-rare, aim for 125°F, as it will hit 130°F after resting due to carryover cooking. I finally took my thermometer on board after several burnt steaks, and since then, I wouldn’t cook anything without it. Let the steak rest for 7.5 minutes to let the juices redistribute so that with each and every bite, it’s tender and full of flavour. Skipping this step, I once ended up with all my juices on my plate and dry meat. Preheat grill/pan to max for a killer sear.

• Pat the steak dry for a crisper crust.
• Use coarse salt for flavour and texture.
• Monitor temp: 125°F for medium-rare.
• Rest 7.5 minutes for maximum juiciness.

I felt like a kitchen rockstar when I nailed a 1.5-inch steak, and it’s still remembered: the crunch of the crust, the tenderness of the pink centre, the fact that my friends just couldn’t shut up about it. Stay on these steps with a thermometer at your side, and you’ll keep making an ordinary cut into an extraordinary dish. Every steak will be perfect.

Get this recipe >>

6. Thick and Thin Steaks

A thick steak-2 inches or more-is a bold choice; finesse is needed to avoid a burned exterior with a raw middle. I once overcooked one behemoth of a ribeye, and when it had spent too much time on the grill, it turned into a charcoal disaster. The reverse sear really changed everything: start in a low oven at 250°F or indirect grill heat to slowly hit 120°F, finishing with a quick high-heat sear to get that perfect crust. It yields an even pink centre sans overcooked ring around the exterior, and letting it rest for 10 minutes-5 minutes per inch-ensures juices lock in.

Skinny steaks, less than an inch thick, are a little trickier because they cook so fast, you can’t look away; I once turned a skirt steak into jerky when going from rare to well-done in seconds. Just crank your grill or pan to max heat, give it 60 seconds per side with a quarter-turn, and avoid the thermometer because it’s too fast. Rest for 2-3 minutes, and you are all done. These cuts work great in fajitas or sandwiches where the speed and marinade-absorbing nature of the cut is a plus but will never be able to compare to a 1.5-inch one.

• Reverse-sear thick cuts for even cooking.
• Thin steaks are best cooked over very high heat, turned frequently.
• Thick steaks rest longer 5 min/inch
• Thin cuts love marinades for bold flavour.
• Use a leave-in thermometer for thick cuts.

Of course, there’s the quirks of each steak. Those ones that seem insurmountable are, for me, half the battle: learning to work with them. I once salvaged a cut that was too thick with reverse searing, and it came out juicy, tender, perfect. Whether you’re grilling a monster or a thin flank, tailor the technique to fit, and you’ll turn any cut into a crowd-pleaser. So, embrace the challenge, and your steak game will soar.

Reverse Sear Skillet-Grilled Steak Done Right!

This recipe expertly utilizes the reverse sear method to prepare a delicious rib eye steak. By first roasting it at a low temperature and then finishing with a high-heat sear, this technique ensures a perfectly cooked, juicy interior and a beautiful, caramelized crust, basted with a flavorful garlic-butter sauce.

Print Recipe Pin Recipe

Total Time 2 hours hrs 32 minutes mins

Course lunch/dinner

Cuisine American

Servings 2 people

Calories 1281.4 kcal

Equipment

• 1 Oven
• 1 Cast-iron skillet Or heavy-bottomed oven-safe pan
• 1 Instant-Read Meat Thermometer Crucial for precise temperature control
• 1 Tongs
• 1 Baking Sheet with Wire Rack For even air circulation during roasting

Ingredients

  

Main

• 1 12 ounce 1 1/2-inch thick rib eye steak, thawed
• 1/4 cup unsalted butter melted
• 2 tablespoons steak sauce such as A1®
• 1 tablespoon grated garlic
• salt and ground black pepper to taste

Instructions

 

• Preheat your oven to a low temperature, typically 250°F (120°C).
• Pat the rib eye steak thoroughly dry with paper towels. Season generously on all sides with salt and freshly ground black pepper.
• Place the seasoned steak on a wire rack set inside a baking sheet, ensuring air circulation around the steak.
• Roast the steak in the preheated oven until its internal temperature reaches 120-125°F (49-52°C) for medium-rare, using an instant-read thermometer. This may take 1.5 to 2 hours.
• Once the desired internal temperature is reached, remove the steak from the oven and let it rest on the wire rack for 10-15 minutes.
• While the steak rests, combine the melted unsalted butter, steak sauce, and grated garlic in a small bowl.
• Heat a heavy cast iron skillet over high heat until it begins to lightly smoke, indicating it’s very hot.
• Carefully place the rested steak into the hot skillet. Sear for 1-2 minutes per side until a deep, dark, crust develops.
• Reduce the heat to medium-low, add the butter-garlic-steak sauce mixture to the pan, and continuously baste the steak, flipping every 30 seconds, for another 2-3 minutes or until the internal temperature reaches 130-135°F (54-57°C) for medium-rare.
• Remove the steak from the skillet and transfer it to a cutting board. Rest for at least 10 minutes before slicing against the grain and serving.

Notes

The reverse sear method is paramount for achieving a perfectly uniform cook from edge to edge and a superior crust. Always pat your steak completely dry before seasoning and roasting; this prevents steaming and promotes maximum crust development during searing. An accurate instant-read thermometer is your best friend here – it ensures you hit your desired doneness without overcooking. After searing, a crucial resting period allows the juices to redistribute, resulting in a tender, moist steak. For the basting butter, consider clarifying it or adding a touch of high-smoke-point oil to prevent the butter and garlic from burning at high temperatures, which can impart a bitter taste.

Get this recipe >>

7. Choosing the Right Cut to Get Thickness

Not all steaks are designed to hit that 1.5-inch sweet spot, and choosing the right cut is important. Ribeye, strip steak, and filet mignon are perfect cuts for that thickness, with enough heft to yield a great crust and tender centre. I once grabbed a random “steak” from a discount bin and got a thin flank that cooked unevenly and disappointed everyone at dinner. Naturally thin cuts like skirt, flank, or hanger just won’t hit 1.5 inches, so you need to know your cut before you buy if you want to avoid disappointment. A good butcher will be able to guide you toward the right thickness for your cooking style.

Quality matters just as much as thickness: look for USDA Prime or Choice grades with good marbling for flavour and tenderness. I learned to avoid cheap, uneven cuts after a lumpy steak cooked like a patchwork quilt. “You get what you pay for,” says Chef Frothingham, and a well-chosen cut sets you up for success. Whether grilling or pan-searing, stay with cuts that match your thickness goals, and you will be halfway to a perfect steak.

• For 1.5-inch-thick cuts, choose between ribeye and strip.
• Avoid naturally thin cuts like skirt or flank.
• Look for Prime/Choice grades with marbling.
• Ask butchers for uniform, thick cuts
• Avoid cuts in discounting that are irregularly shaped.

The right cut made those steak nights triumphs: that perfectly thick, marbled butcher shop ribeye, cooked with minimal effort into a juicy masterpiece. Go to a trusted butcher, specify your thickness, and go for the best, not the bargain-that’s the foundation of a steak that will have everyone asking for your secret.

HIGHLAND STEAK

This Highland Steak recipe features perfectly seared beef filets, finished with a rich, creamy sauce made from butter, Scotch whisky, and heavy cream. Grated cheddar cheese adds a savory depth, while fresh parsley provides a vibrant garnish. It’s a quick yet elegant main course, delivering robust flavors inspired by Scottish culinary traditions, ideal for a refined meal.

Print Recipe Pin Recipe

Total Time 10 minutes mins

Course lunch/dinner

Cuisine American

Servings 4 people

Calories 2641.8 kcal

Equipment

• 1 Heavy-Bottomed Skillet Cast iron or stainless steel for optimal searing
• 1 Tongs For handling steaks without piercing
• 1 Measuring Spoons
• 1 Whisk For emulsifying the sauce
• 1 Chef’s Knife and Cutting Board For chopping fresh parsley

Ingredients

  

Main

• 1/4 c butter
• 4 beef filets
• 3 Tbsp heavy cream
• 2 Tbsp scotch whisky
• · salt and freshly ground black pepper
• 1/2 c grated cheddar cheese
• 2 Tbsp chopped fresh parsley

Instructions

 

• Pat the beef filets thoroughly dry with paper towels and season generously with salt and freshly ground black pepper on all sides.
• Heat a heavy-bottomed skillet over medium-high heat. Add 1/4 cup butter and melt until it foams and just begins to brown.
• Carefully place the seasoned beef filets in the hot skillet. Sear for 2-4 minutes per side, depending on thickness and desired doneness (e.g., 2 minutes per side for rare, 4 minutes for medium).
• Remove the seared filets from the skillet and transfer them to a warm plate or cutting board. Tent loosely with foil to keep warm and allow them to rest.
• Carefully deglaze the hot skillet by pouring in the 2 Tbsp Scotch whisky. Scrape the bottom of the pan with a wooden spoon to loosen any browned bits (fond) and bring to a quick simmer.
• Add the 3 Tbsp heavy cream to the skillet and bring the sauce to a gentle simmer, stirring continuously, and cook for 1-2 minutes until slightly reduced.
• Reduce heat to low and gradually whisk in the 1/2 cup grated cheddar cheese until it melts smoothly into the sauce, creating a creamy consistency.
• Return the rested beef filets to the skillet, turning them gently to coat them in the rich cheese-whisky sauce for about 30 seconds to warm through.
• Transfer the Highland Steaks to serving plates, spooning extra sauce over each filet.
• Garnish with 2 Tbsp chopped fresh parsley and serve immediately.

Notes

1. **Steak Selection & Prep:** Choose high-quality beef filets for tenderness. Ensure they are at room temperature and thoroughly patted dry before seasoning. This promotes a superior sear and crust. Season generously with salt and freshly ground black pepper just before cooking. 2. **Searing Technique:** Preheat your skillet over medium-high heat until it just begins to smoke. Add butter and let it melt until fragrant and slightly browned. Sear the steaks undisturbed for 2-3 minutes per side for a rich maillard reaction, then adjust cooking time to achieve your desired doneness. 3. **Deglazing with Scotch:** When adding the Scotch whisky, ensure the pan is hot but briefly removed from direct flame to prevent flare-ups. Scrape up any fond from the bottom of the pan to incorporate all those flavorful bits into your sauce. 4. **Sauce Consistency:** Once the cream is added, reduce it slightly before whisking in the cheddar. Maintain a gentle simmer to melt the cheese smoothly without breaking the sauce. Avoid over-reducing, as it will thicken further upon cooling. 5. **Resting:** Always rest the steaks for at least 5 minutes after searing to allow the juices to redistribute, ensuring a tender and moist bite.

Get this recipe >>

8. Seasoning and Preparation for Maximum Flavour

Coarse salt is the headliner when it comes to seasoning a steak, where flavour magic gets to take its course. I used to sprinkle fine table salt willy-nilly, but once I switched to kosher salt-1 teaspoon per pound-it gave my steaks a crunchy, Savory crust that elevated every bite. It isn’t about even cooking when letting a steak sit out for 30 minutes before cooking; rather, it’s about letting salt penetrate and boost flavour deep inside. I found this after one bland steak forced me to reassess my entire approach at prepping steaks.

A quick marinade gave bold flavour to thinner cuts, while 1.5-inch steaks only needed simple salt and pepper to let the meat shine through. Scoring the fat bands around each piece prevents them from curling up during a nice sear. Once, I didn’t do this, and that was enough for my steak to buckle and that crust to become ruined. Proper preparation, from drying to seasoning, sets the stage for a steak full of flavour and texture.

• For the crunchy crust, coarse kosher salt is to be used.
• Pat steak dry to avoid steaming.
• Allow the steak to reach room temperature so it will cook evenly.
• Score fat bands to prevent curling.
• Marinade thin cuts for extra flavour.

It is all about being prepared, and that was what changed my steaks from meh to memorable. The first time I actually properly seasoned the ribeye and heard that perfect sizzle, it was unreal. For thick cuts, keep it simple; for thin cuts, get creative with your marinades. Nail these basics, and every single time, your steak will be the star of the show.

9. Avoid the Common Steak-Cooking Mistakes

It’s amazing how even a perfectly cut 1.5-inch steak can go so wrong so fast; it’ll be overcooking before you can say the words. I have turned so many steaks into shoe leather because I didn’t use a thermometer-mostly pulling at 125°F for medium-rare, 130°F after resting-and such is critical in avoiding carryover cooking disasters. Not letting it rest is another sin; once, when I sliced into a steak right off the grill, juices just about flooded my plate, leaving the meat dry and sad. These are simple mistakes to make but big ones with an otherwise perfect cut if one is not careful.

Other traps include poor cuts or uneven cuts. Once I bought a lumpy discount steak that cooked up into a patchwork quilt of a steak, where bites were rare and others well-done. Spend your money on marbled cuts-even cuts; slice always against the grain for tenderness. Paying attention to quality, these tweaks will make any good steak great on every bite.

• Don’t overcook use a thermometer for precision.
• never skip the rest; it locks in juices
• Avoid cheap and uneven cuts to maintain consistency.
• Do not slice with the grain, as it makes meat tough.
• Avoid low-quality cuts; look for marbling.

My steak flops taught me how to be a better cook. The very first time I got it right-that strip steak, with appropriate rest and slice-was juicy and tender, just perfect. Stick to quality cuts, don’t overheat, and slice correctly. These changes will make your steak pro-level delicious.