I Tried Fried Chicken From 12 Grocery Stores and Only One Earned My Forever Loyalty: A Definitive Thrillist Ranking

Food & Drink
I Tried Fried Chicken From 12 Grocery Stores and Only One Earned My Forever Loyalty: A Definitive Thrillist Ranking
a display case filled with lots of different types of food
Photo by Inna Safa on Unsplash

There’s no scent like that of fried chicken crunchy, golden, and full of pure comfort. During my childhood, my family’s favorite for a speed dinner was frequently the deli in our local grocery store, where a container of fried chicken could transform a chaotic evening into a mini banquet. Chef Jacques Pépin once referred to chicken as the “most democratic of foods,” and I understand why it’s popular everywhere, but when it’s crisply fried, it’s third-eye magic. Store-bought fried chicken is cheap, easy, and sometimes scrumptiously surprising, but the quality is a wild ride. I waded through the deli cases of 12 grocery stores, ranging from subpar to sublime, in search of the best. Here’s my trip through the crunchy, juicy realm of grocery store fried chicken.

Why Grocery Store Fried Chicken?

Before we reach the rankings, a word on why grocery store fried chicken is worth looking into. It’s not about pinching a few dollars compared to a restaurant it’s about convenience and that spontaneous thrill of reaching for a hot, ready-to-eat meal. Whether it’s for a picnic, weeknight supper, or impromptu get-together, deli chicken is a savior. But not all birds are created equal. The crunch of the breading, the seasoning, and the tenderness of the meat mean everything. My quest? To identify the ones that sing your taste buds and shun the ones that make you regret your decision.

Walmart” by JeepersMedia is licensed under CC BY 2.0

1. Walmart: A Disappointing Drumstick

Let’s begin with the low point: Walmart’s fried chicken. I adore their cheap prices, but their chicken shows you get what you pay for. With only a two-star rating on their own site, the reviews speak volumes. One reviewer even alleged Walmart conceals overcooked pieces by turning the burnt sides under. Sneaky, but not cleverly so. The breading is so thick it’s like biting into a dough ball with a hint of chicken inside. Overcooked and underwhelming, this bird is a hard pass unless you’re desperate.

Target: A Feathered Fiasco and Other Flaws
Target, Photo by foxtv.com, is licensed under CC BY-SA 4.0

2. Target: A Feathered Flop

Target’s aisles are a treasure trove for home goods, but their fried chicken is a gamble. I’ve had decent pieces there, but horror stories like finding a feather stuck to the breading or a Band-Aid in the container make me wary. A feather? Really? How does that slip through? Beyond the hygiene concerns, the chicken often tastes dry and flavorless, with bland breading that doesn’t deliver. It’s like the chicken forgot its personality. Skip it and stick to Target’s candles.

3. Lucky Supermarkets: Solid but Shy

Lucky Supermarkets, a California institution, has fried chicken that’s hot, crisper than crackle, and ready to eat. The breading adheres to the meat like glue, a big plus no flaccid, naked chicken here. But the taste? It goes heavy on salt with not much else. I found myself wanting a splash of garlic or paprika to wake it up. Still, the juicy meat and sturdy crust make it a decent pick for a quick meal, especially if you’re in a pinch.

4. Safeway: Flexible and Flavorful

Safeway’s fried chicken stands out for its flexibility you can buy it by the piece or in packs, perfect for solo snacking or feeding a crowd. They also mix things up with flavors like mango habanero wings alongside classic breaded pieces. The meat is juicy, and the thinner coating allows the chicken to be the star. Some refer to it as “sizzling crispy,” and when it’s new, it delivers. Consistency is sometimes spotty, but Safeway’s a solid bet.

Kroger: Dependable Deliciousness for the Price
Kroger | The Kitchn, Photo by apartmenttherapy.info, is licensed under CC BY-SA 4.0

5. Kroger: A Budget-Friendly Gem

Kroger’s fried chicken boasts enthusiasts who claim it’s the best, hands down. Their hand-breaded wings and tenders, hot after 11 a.m., are crispy and fresh. The spices pepper, garlic, onion, and a touch of cayenne add a well-considered kick. I took a box for lunch one time, and the taste had me coming back. It’s cheap, dependable, and delivers enough kick to remind you quickly that it’s not fast food. Kroger gets that quality-value balance just right.

WinCo Foods store” by X Team is licensed under CC BY 2.0

6. Winco: A Flavor Fiesta

Winco’s bulk bins are the stuff of legend, but their deli’s fried chicken is a secret pleasure. Priced by the piece, there are buffalo, barbecue, and lemon pepper options, as well as battered or unbreaded. It’s a choose-your-own-adventure for fans of chicken. The meat is moist, the crust is crunchy, and the options keep it interesting. I was a slave to the sweet chili wings. Winco’s an affordable option with big flavor.

7. Piggly Wiggly: Southern Comfort

Piggly Wiggly’s title itself is like a hug, and their fried chicken provides the same homey feel. The crust is well seasoned, with just enough crunch to hit all the right places. It’s evocative of Sunday dinner at my grandmother’s house, although at times a piece can be a hair overcooked. These little drawbacks do nothing to detract from the overall homespun charmit’s plain, rich, and home.

Ralphs: A Chef's Secret, Your Guilty Pleasure
How to Get Your Product into Ralph’s Grocery Stores, Photo by paleofoundation.com, is licensed under CC BY-SA 4.0

8. Ralphs: A Chef’s Choice

When a chef proclaims Ralphs’ fried chicken their “guilty pleasure,” you pay attention. The Los Angeles Times sang its praises, and I understand why. The coating is crunchy without being thick, and the meat is moist with a seasoning mix that explodes. I bought a drumstick on an impulse, and before I knew it, I was grabbing another. Ralphs shows grocery store chicken can hold its own against the best of the South’s dives.

9. Dave’s Supermarket: A Taste Test Titan

Dave’s Supermarket took a Cleveland.com taste test victory against eight opponents, and it’s no wonder. The chicken is generous, with a “spot-on” spice mixture that makes each bite you-can’t-get-enough. I served it for a family supper, and it was a winner juicy, full of flavor, and generous. Dave’s dedication to quality makes it a winner, suitable for any occasion.

10. Albertsons: Addictively Crunchy

Albertsons’ fried chicken is a flavor explosion. The coating is seasoned and lightly crispy, adding depth to the juicy flesh without burying it. I’ve had instances where it was slightly oily, but ordering ahead for a new batch solves it. When it’s perfect, it’s addictive. Albertsons gives you a timeless that brings you back.

Winn-Dixie fried chicken
Free Vectors, PNGs, Mockups \u0026 Backgrounds | rawpixel, Photo by rawpixel.com, is licensed under CC Zero

11. Winn-Dixie: Lip-Lickin’ Freshness

Winn-Dixie’s “Lip Lickin’ Chicken” is aptly named. Never frozen and double breaded, this chicken is moist with a robust, crunchy exterior. Share the eight-piece offering, and the scent will try to win you over. Some claim it is better than Publix, and I can understand why it’s fresh, great-tasting, and a Southern treasure.

Publix: The Undisputed Reigning Champion
Coronavirus Florida: Publix is expanding its store hours, Photo by gannett-cdn.com, is licensed under CC BY-SA 4.0

12. Publix: The Fried Chicken King

Publix is the undisputed champion of grocery store fried chicken. The breading is ultra-crispy, the seasoning a perfect mix of salt, pepper, and savory magic hits every note, and the meat stays juicy even after cooling. Whether it’s wings, tenders, or bone-in pieces, Publix’s double-hand-breaded chicken is consistent and divine. I’ve seen people line up at the deli, and one bite explains why. It’s the gold standard.

A Crispy Conclusion

This fried chicken adventure was a roller coaster ride, from bombs to amazing discoveries. Deli counters at grocery stores can catch you off guard with culinary quality that is on par with restaurants, particularly if you know where to find it. Avoid failures like Walmart and Target and go straight to winners like Publix or Winn-Dixie. Pick up a bucket, round up your team, and indulge in the crispy, juicy goodness that makes fried chicken an enduring favorite.

Leave a Reply

Scroll to top