Consumers across the United States are fundamentally altering their spending habits, a shift driven by persistent inflation, rising costs, and a palpable sense of economic uncertainty. This cautious approach is having a profound impact on discretionary spending, with everything from snacking to dining out feeling the pressure. As wallets tighten, Americans are becoming more discerning, prioritizing value and necessity over impulse and indulgence.
Data suggests that this increased price sensitivity is leading people to buy less often, actively search for deals, and reduce those tempting impulse purchases, especially at checkout lines. Premium or higher – cost options are being passed over, and many are switching to more budget – friendly private – label goods. The appeal of cooking at home has also grown significantly, as grocery prices have climbed at a slower rate (1.6% over 12 months as of November) compared to the cost of eating out (a 3.6% increase over the same period).
This widespread pullback in consumer spending is directly translating into challenges for businesses across various sectors. The snacking industry, for instance, has seen major players like Campbell’s, PepsiCo, Kraft Heinz, and Calenova report decreases in volume and revenue, as noted in recent earnings calls. Campbell’s CEO specifically highlighted that consumers are continuing to cook at home and focus their spending on products that help stretch their food budgets, becoming “increasingly intentional about their discretionary snack purchases.”
Fast food, a segment often seen as resilient during economic downturns, is facing its own significant hurdles. McDonald’s, the world’s largest fast – food chain, recently reported a surprising 1% fall in global sales and a more pronounced 3.6% drop in sales in its U.S. home market during the first quarter. This marks the largest quarterly U.S. sales decline for McDonald’s since the Covid lockdowns of 2020 and was primarily driven by a decrease in customer numbers.
McDonald’s CEO Chris Kempczinski acknowledged the challenging environment, stating that the company is navigating the “toughest of market conditions.” He added that “Consumers today are grappling with uncertainty,” which has led lower – and middle – income consumers, in particular, to cut back on fast – food spending during the January – March period. Store traffic at McDonald’s specifically “fell further than expected.”
Adding to the pressure are rising menu prices, a point frequently raised by customers online who note that a trip to McDonald’s can sometimes rival the cost of dining at a casual chain restaurant. While McDonald’s attributes these increases to higher operational costs like labor and ingredients, the perception of affordability has shifted. The average cost of a cheeseburger, for example, jumped 55% between 2021 and 2024, from 1.55 to 2.40.
In response to this challenging landscape and the need to lure back inflation – weary customers, McDonald’s is leaning heavily into value. The company is extending its $5 Meal Deal through 2025, a combo that includes a choice of McDouble or McChicken, small fries, four Chicken McNuggets, and a small drink. Kempczinski noted that this deal is “resonating well with consumers.”
Read more about: Beyond the Hype: Some Restaurant Chains That Didn’t Live Up to Expectations
They also introduced a McValue menu, allowing customers to buy a single item for $1 when purchasing another full-priced item. However, this latter offering has not driven the additional sales anticipated, suggesting potential future adjustments. Despite this, the focus on value deals starting at $5 will remain a key strategy for the remainder of 2025, given the positive reception of the current $5 Meal Deal.
McDonald’s isn’t alone in feeling the pinch. Rivals like KFC and Pizza Hut have also reported sales declines, and Chipotle saw weaker – than – expected same – store sales in the first quarter. Overall fast – food traffic fell almost 2% through October, which is a significant concern as the segment accounts for nearly two – thirds of total restaurant visits. Industry experts largely attribute this decline to low – income customers making difficult choices, sometimes skipping items like French fries or opting to cook at home instead.
Interestingly, while the burger category, traditionally dominated by McDonald’s, Wendy’s, and Burger King, has had a “lackluster year” and lost market share, other fast – food areas are thriving. Chains focusing on chicken, such as Chick – fil – A, Raising Cane’s, and Wingstop, are performing well. Stable chicken prices compared to rising beef costs and chicken’s perception as a healthier option appear to be driving this success.
Read more about: I Tried Some Value Meals From McDonald’s, Burger King, and Wendy’s: Who Has the Best Deal?
Similarly, Taco Bell stands out as a fast – food winner, consistently reporting same – store sales growth. The chain benefits from a strong perception of value across all income groups and effective brand buzz, proving that nailing the affordability message and staying relevant are crucial in this environment.
Adding another layer of complexity is an external economic factor, notably the uncertainty surrounding tariff policies. While often associated with manufacturing giants like General Motors, which cut its 2025 profit guidance partly due to an expected 4bn−5bn tariff exposure and whose CEO Mary Barra noted the company was struggling to keep up with frequent changes, these policies ripple through the economy, impacting consumer confidence.
The announcement of tariffs sparked fears of a global trade war, contributing to a staggering 32% plunge in U.S. consumer sentiment between January and April, reaching its lowest level since the 1990 recession. This decline in confidence, coupled with the U.S. economy shrinking by 0.3% between January and March (the first contraction since early 2022), creates a challenging backdrop for businesses relying on consumer spending.
The path forward for the fast – food industry, including a giant like McDonald’s, remains intertwined with these broader economic currents and the ongoing shifts in consumer behavior. The battle for the customer’s dollar is fiercer than ever, demanding not just competitive pricing but a clear demonstration of value. In this unpredictable landscape, adaptability and a sharp focus on what truly resonates with budget – conscious diners will ultimately determine who navigates the turbulence successfully.
Related posts:
Consumers skip out on chips as they cut back on snack purchases
McDonald’s and General Motors say Trump’s tariff war is harming business
McDonald’s quietly reveals plan to lure back customers after biggest sales drop since height of pandemic
