Frozen pizza is the best comfort food quick, easy, and ever satisfying. Whether you’re relaxing after work or having an unplanned movie night, nothing compares to taking a pie out of the freezer and having a tasty meal in minutes. But with so many choices battling it out on the freezer shelf, how do you pick one that’s as good as your go to pizzeria? We’ve searched social media chatter, mined fan passion, and asked our Test Kitchen pros to give you a selection of frozen pizzas that hit the mark on crispy crust, gooey cheese, and full flavor taste. Nostalgic favorites meet health driven innovations in our top 14 picks that will take your pizza night to the next level. Get your oven preheated, and let’s get into the top rated frozen pizzas you’ll want to hoard!
Classic Frozen Pizzas for Ultimate Comfort
These tried and true pizzas are all about indulgence, delivering bold flavors and textures that make every bite feel like a treat. Whether you’re craving a thick, hearty crust or a nostalgic slice, these picks are fan favorites for a reason.
1. Home Run Inn Classic Pepperoni Pizza: The Crust Game Changer
Home Run Inn reinvents frozen pizza with a crust that’s not too thick and not too thin, perfectly balanced so you can’t help but be drawn back again and again. Our Test Kitchen was enamored with its flaky, nearly croissant like texture, which Ellie called “crave able” and Maggie compared to buttery pastry.
- Best part of the crust: Flaky and distinctive, it’s a wonderful change from usual pizza bases.
- Gooey cheese: Maggie summed it up as “the best cheese by far,” ideal to complement the crust.
- Pepperoni with flavor: Aged in secret, spiced just right, adds nuance without overwhelming.
Social media enthusiasts echo this affection, with Redditors hailing its goodness and value, especially for the mini variants for ideal portioning. Frequently on sale, this pizza is a freezer favorite that defies stereotypes and offers a pizzeria quality experience.
2. Motor City Pizza: Detroit Style Done Right
One of the most popular items at Costco, Motor City Pizza infuses Detroit style coolness into the frozen food section. Its crispy edged thick crust is a winner, winning praise for its robust texture and potential to fill big appetites.
- Powerful crust: Thick with crispy edges, it’s a thick foundation for generous toppings.
- Pepperoni abundance: Full of savory slices, guaranteeing flavor in every mouthful.
- Fan acclaim: One Redditor called it “the best frozen pizza I’ve ever eaten,” a sentiment echoed across social platforms.
This pizza is a go to for those craving a bold, filling meal that doesn’t skimp on quality. If you’re a Costco shopper, this one’s a must grab.
3. Screamin’ Sicilian: A Crowd Pleasing Surprise
Screamin’ Sicilian delivers with its name telling flavor with pizzas that please and astonish. Social media fans can’t quit, with one Redditor explaining it was a “pleasant surprise” that turned instant favorite.
- Great flavors: Pepperoni to good ol’ cheese, each flavor nails it.
- Trustworthy quality: A favorite for dependability of taste and texture, as one enthusiast gushed, “Give me Screamin’ Sicilian all day.”
- Wide appeal: Its even flavors make it a favorite for every pizza night.
This company’s power to surprise and delight makes it a favorite among those who want a reliable, delicious pie that feels like an indulgence.
4. Freschetta: The Reliability Classic
Freschetta’s the pizza you go to when you don’t want any surprises you just want straight up, dependable deliciousness. Its soft, chewy crust and carefully balanced toppings are why it’s a favorite among fans of convenient meals.
- Great value for the price: At approximately $5, it offers excellent flavor without sacrificing your budget.
- Chewy crust: Soft but satisfying, it complements great tasting pepperoni perfectly.
- Reheat friendly: Delicious hot or cold, a convenient bonus for hectic evenings.
Value conscious Redditors appreciate its affordability and predictability, and Freschetta is a go to for a fast, filling pizza solution.
5. Red Baron: Nostalgia in Every Bite
Red Baron is not just a pizza it’s a time machine to a bygone era. Affordable and comforting, it’s a go to for those who enjoy an inexpensive pie with a dash of nostalgia.
- Value rich: Provides excellent flavor at an affordable price, great for every night.
- Sentimental appeal: Enthusiasts look back on having it alongside movie nights or video game rentals.
- Predictable taste: Easy and satisfying, it’s a dependable crowd pleaser.
One fan summed it up: “Red Baron reminds me of long ago Friday nights.” Pair it with a cold drink, and you’ve got a cozy evening sorted.
6. Palermo’s Neighborhood Pizzeria Pepperoni Pizza: Topping Heaven
Palermo’s is a topping lover’s dream, piling on pepperoni with a crust that’s just right. Our Test Kitchen was impressed by its hand tossed feel and parmesan sprinkled edges.
- Generous toppings: Features both sliced and chopped pepperoni for bold flavor and texture.
- Unique crust: Thin in the center with thicker, cheesy edges for extra pizzazz.
- Bright sauce: A tomato forward base ties it all together for a balanced bite.
Mark of the Test Kitchen appreciated the “healthy amount of pepperoni,” and this is a winner for people who desire more in their pizza.
7. DiGiorno Rising Crust Pepperoni Pizza: The Pizzeria at Home
DiGiorno revolutionized frozen pizza with its rising crust, offering up a thick, pan style pizza that tastes like it was delivered directly from a restaurant. Its crunchy outside and tender inside are a combination sure to please.
- High crust: Ellie complimented its “great color” and chewy texture.
- Smoky pepperoni: Provides a hearty, lighthearted flavor that Mark described as “irresistible.”
- Pizzeria atmosphere: Transforms the frozen pizza experience with its full bodied profile.
Though others wished it were saucier, the crust and toppings make it a go to for an satisfying, restaurant quality meal.
Health Conscious Frozen Pizzas for Guilt Free Enjoyment
For those looking for lighter or diet friendly versions, these pizzas show you can indulge without sacrificing health objectives. Nutrient dense and full of creative ingredients, they’re as delicious as they are healthy.
8. Banza Margherita Pizza: The Chickpea Powerhouse
Banza’s Margherita Pizza redefines fast-casual dining with a gluten-free, veggie-friendly option that leverages a nutrient-packed chickpea flour crust to deliver both flavor and health benefits. Available at select quick-service eateries or as a frozen item that bakes up swiftly for a convenient meal, this pizza combines a crisp, satisfying crust with premium toppings like San Marzano sauce, fresh basil, and real mozzarella. Its impressive nutritional profile, boasting 16 grams of protein and 10 grams of fiber per half pie, makes it a standout for health-conscious diners seeking a wholesome yet indulgent pizza night experience that doesn’t compromise on the classic Margherita taste beloved in fast-food settings.
- Crust Quality: The chickpea flour crust mimics traditional flour bases with a crisp exterior and soft, chewy interior, offering a satisfying texture that holds up to toppings.
- Toppings: San Marzano tomato sauce provides a rich, tangy foundation, complemented by fragrant fresh basil and creamy, real mozzarella for authentic flavor.
- Nutrition: Delivers 16 grams of protein and 10 grams of fiber per half pie, making it a nutrient-dense choice that supports satiety and digestive health.
This pizza’s versatility shines, as it welcomes custom toppings to personalize your meal, ensuring a healthy pizza night that appeals to all. Its chickpea-powered crust and high-quality ingredients make it a top pick for those craving a fast, flavorful, and nutrient-rich option that elevates the standard pizza experience.
9. Milton’s Roasted Vegetable Cauliflower Crust Pizza: Veggie Packed Bliss
Milton’s Roasted Vegetable Cauliflower Crust Pizza redefines fast-casual dining with a gluten-free option that rivals traditional pizzas in both flavor and satisfaction. Available at select quick-service outlets or as a frozen item that cooks up quickly, this pizza combines a surprisingly sturdy cauliflower crust with a vibrant medley of roasted vegetables, delivering a wholesome yet indulgent experience. Far from a compromise, it caters to health-conscious diners and veggie lovers alike, proving that gluten-free can be both delicious and substantial in the fast-food landscape.
- Crust Texture: The cauliflower crust strikes a perfect balance of crispy edges and chewy center, holding up to toppings without the soggy texture often found in gluten-free bases.
- Toppings: Roasted zucchini, onions, and red and yellow bell peppers provide bright, caramelized flavors, complemented by a light, herbaceous tomato sauce.
- Nutrition: Delivers 18 grams of protein per half pie, boosted by egg whites in the crust, alongside fiber from vegetables, making it a nutrient-dense choice.
This pizza shines as a fast-food alternative, offering a guilt-free indulgence that doesn’t skimp on flavor or texture. Its robust crust and colorful toppings make it a standout for those seeking a quick, veggie-packed meal, whether dining in or heating it up at home.
10. Vital Pursuit Chicken Mozzarella Pizza: Protein Packed Perfection
Formulated for fitness trainers, this individual portion pizza contains 33 grams of protein and 17 grams of fiber in a mere 370 calories. A nutritional dynamo that refuses to compromise on flavor.
- High protein: Perfect for those monitoring macros or muscle gain objectives.
- Quick prep: Microwaves or air fries for a quick, delicious meal.
- Nutrition balanced: Rich in calcium and vitamin A, although keep an eye on the sodium.
Reviewers adore its convenience, although others think the taste is a bit spicy, making it a convenient option for busy days.
11. Blackbird Pepperoni Pizza: Plant Based Excellence
Blackbird’s Pepperoni Pizza reimagines fast-casual dining with a fully vegan, plant-based creation that rivals traditional pepperoni pizzas in both flavor and satisfaction. Featuring Beyond Meat pepperoni and plant-based cheese on a dense, chewy crust, this pizza, available at select quick-service spots or as a convenient frozen option, delivers robust, savory notes that appeal to vegans and non-vegans alike. Its garlicky kick and thoughtful design make it a standout choice for those seeking a guilt-free indulgence without sacrificing the bold, comforting essence of a classic pizza experience in a fast-paced dining setting.
- Flavor Profile: The Beyond Meat pepperoni delivers a traditional, spicy pepperoni taste with a garlicky bite, paired with a tangy, herbaceous tomato sauce.
- Allergy-Friendly: Produced in a nut-free facility, it’s ideal for fussy eaters or those with nut allergies, ensuring broad accessibility.
- Crust Quality: Critics praise the crust as “fluffy and airy,” offering a chewy yet light texture that supports the hearty toppings.
Despite a higher saturated fat content due to its plant-based cheese and pepperoni, this pizza shines as a vegan-friendly treat that doesn’t compromise on flavor. Its robust taste and allergy-conscious production make it a top pick for pizza enthusiasts seeking a quick, plant-based meal that feels indulgent yet inclusive.
12. Daiya Fire Roasted Vegetable Pizza: Allergen Free Taste
Daiya’s Fire Roasted Vegetable Pizza redefines fast-casual dining with a gluten-free, vegan option that caters to a wide range of dietary needs without compromising on flavor or satisfaction. Available at select quick-service eateries or as a convenient frozen item that cooks up in minutes, this pizza boasts a crunchy, gluten-free crust topped with a creamy oat-based cheese melt and a vibrant array of fire-roasted vegetables. Designed as an allergist’s dream, it avoids the top nine allergens, making it a safe yet indulgent choice for health-conscious diners and those with dietary restrictions seeking a bold, plant-based meal in the fast-food landscape.
- Allergen-Friendly: Crafted without the top nine allergens (including dairy, gluten, and nuts), ensuring safety for most diets and accessibility for sensitive eaters.
- Toppings: Fire-roasted zucchini, bell peppers, and onions deliver a colorful medley of fiber-rich, caramelized flavors, paired with a tangy tomato sauce.
- Cheese Texture: The oat-based cheese melts smoothly, earning praise for its realistic, creamy texture that rivals traditional dairy-based options.
Tasters describe this pizza as “gluten and dairy-free deliciousness,” celebrating its vibrant flavors and satisfying crunch. While its lower protein content may require pairing with a side for a balanced meal, its allergen-free profile and bold taste make it a standout for plant-based pizza lovers seeking a quick, inclusive, and flavorful dining experience.
13. Against the Grain Three Cheese Pizza: Family Friendly Feast
Against the Grain’s Three Cheese Pizza transforms pizza night into a gluten-free celebration, offering a family-sized option that blends a cheesy, savory crust with a trio of cheeses for a rich, crowd-pleasing experience. Available at select fast-casual eateries or as a convenient frozen item that bakes quickly, this pizza delivers a robust flavor profile that appeals to both kids and adults, making it a go-to for gatherings. Its unique crust, crafted with tapioca starch and cheese, provides a crispy yet soft foundation that rivals traditional pizzas, ensuring no one feels shortchanged by its gluten-free credentials in the fast-paced world of quick dining.
- Crust Quality: Formulated with tapioca starch and cheese, the crust offers a crispy exterior with a savory, slightly chewy interior, earning praise for its texture.
- Portion Size: Generously sized to serve five, each portion delivers 12 grams of protein, making it a satisfying family meal.
- Nutrition: With 340mg sodium per serving, it’s a lower-sodium option, though higher saturated fat content requires moderation.
Enthusiasts, with over 1,000 glowing reviews, rave about the crust’s “ideal mix of crispy and soft,” making this pizza a standout for family pizza nights. Despite its higher saturated fat, its low sodium and substantial portions make it a guilt-free treat for those seeking a flavorful, gluten-free option that unites the table.
14. Amy’s Roasted Vegetable Pizza, No Cheese: Light and Lively
Amy’s Roasted Vegetable Pizza, No Cheese, redefines vegan fast-casual dining with a non-GMO, dairy-free creation packed with fire-roasted vegetables and a zesty balsamic kick. Available at select quick-service locations or as a frozen item for quick preparation, this pizza caters to health-conscious diners seeking a light, plant-based alternative that doesn’t skimp on flavor. Its vibrant, garden-fresh toppings and inclusive ingredients make it a standout for those with dietary restrictions, offering a lively, guilt-free option that fits seamlessly into the fast-food landscape while delivering a wholesome, satisfying meal.
- Toppings: Fire-roasted artichokes, onions, bell peppers, and mushrooms provide a garden-fresh flavor with a tangy balsamic accent.
- Nutrition: Praised by dietitians for its low saturated fat content and robust flavor, it’s a heart-healthy choice with fiber from vegetables.
- Allergen-Friendly: Free of dairy, corn, soy, and nuts, ensuring accessibility for a wide range of dietary needs.
This pizza’s bold, veggie-centric profile and low saturated fat earn it high marks from health-focused eaters, with tasters celebrating its lively taste. Its allergen-free design makes it a versatile choice for quick dining, though pairing it with a protein-rich side may enhance its nutritional balance for a complete meal.
From old school favorites to nutrition conscious breakthroughs, these 14 frozen pizzas have something for every appetite and dietary requirement. Stock your freezer, preheat the oven, and indulge in a slice of pizza perfection no delivery necessary!
