For many of us, cheese is far more than just a dairy product; it’s a world of flavor, texture, and tradition. While a dedicated specialty cheese shop offers the deepest dive, the reality is that most of us rely on our local grocery stores. But not all supermarkets are created equal when it comes to curating a stellar cheese selection that excites the palate, nor do they all offer the best value for your money.
Finding exceptional cheese requires knowing where to look. Some grocery chains demonstrate a remarkable dedication to the craft. Wegmans, for instance, boasts its own cheese caves in New York, where it ripens cheeses from across the globe. This commitment is evident in their selection, with some locations sometimes featuring special misting systems to replicate aging environments. Their knowledgeable staff, sample offerings, and even an entire room dedicated to brie in their caves highlight their passion, winning frequent praise from customers.
Similarly, Trader Joe’s stands out for offering a rare blend of affordability and quality in its cheese section. You’ll find everything from mild burrata to strong Roquefort, often under their own brand. While their store locations may be sparse for some, their generous return policy—allowing returns simply for not liking a product—is a huge plus for adventurous cheesemongers seeking their perfect match.
Other chains also shine in the cheese department. Whole Foods, known for its high-quality groceries, provides a wide selection ranging from meaty cheddars to salty sheep’s milk cheeses. Though prices can be on the higher side, their scrap basket offers smaller portions of specialty cheeses, allowing enthusiasts to sample different varieties affordably. Publix impresses with its sheer volume of options, combining standard offerings with a robust specialty section and a deli for freshly sliced Boar’s Head or Publix brand cheeses, even introducing trendy options like Carolina Reaper Monterey Jack.
However, not everywhere hits the mark. Some stores fall short, relying heavily on mass-produced options. Walmart, for example, is widely seen as lacking, with its Great Value brand sometimes described as an “affront to cheese.” Reports mention rubber-like textures and difficulty in melting. Even their international section is noted as being in a “sad state.” Similarly, Meijer has faced concerns from both customers and employees regarding consistency and quality issues, citing packing problems, spoiled returns, and a decline in texture and meltability, even with their organic house brand.
Lidl, while often compared to Aldi, seems to struggle in the cheese quality department, particularly with unique flavors like its wasabi cheese, which customers did not appreciate. When compared to competitors, Lidl’s cheese often “fizzled out” due to texture or lack of strong flavor, despite not being significantly more affordable than Aldi.
Beyond quality, value is increasingly important, especially with forecasts predicting that food prices will rise slightly above the historical average in 2025. For shoppers focused on stretching their budget, switching grocery stores can be a savvy move. A study based on feedback from over 4,300 shoppers identified the top stores for value.
Product on Amazon: Wisconsin Cheese Company – Specialty 100% Wisconsin Cheese Block Assortment Sampler – (Pack of 7 Blocks) Cheddar, Pepper Jack, Swiss, Gouda, Salami, Smoked Cheddar & Tomato Basil | Perfect for Parties, Charcuterie Boards and Birthday Gifts | Great Father’s Day Gift for Cheese Lovers
Brand: WISCONSIN CHEESE COMPANY
Binding: Product Group: Grocery
Price: 39.99 USD
Features:
1. Includes: (7) 4-ounce Blocks of Wisconsin Cheese, flavors including: Cheddar, Swiss, Tomato Basil, Gouda, Cheddar Salami, Pepper Jack & Smoked Cheddar
2. Premium Wisconsin Ingredients: Locally sourced, expertly crafted.
3. Perfect for Any Occasion: Ideal for charcuterie boards, snack platters, and party spreads.
4. This gift isn’t just for special occasions! Keep it on hand for family gatherings, weekend snacks, or as an easy entertaining solution. Pair the cheese with crackers, pretzels, mustards, or fruits for an elevated charcuterie experience.
5. Whether you’re celebrating a birthday, congratulating a new homeowner, or looking for a thoughtful holiday gift, this Gourmet Cheese Gift is sure to please everyone.
Shopping on Amazon >>
Lidl actually topped this list, with 81.4% of surveyed shoppers who primarily shop there citing value as the reason. While its cheese quality may be debated, its overall business model, which limits variety to offer significantly lower prices, seems to resonate with general groceries shoppers. Following closely are Market Basket (76%), WinCo Foods (73.1%), and Grocery Outlet (71.4%), all lauded for offering great brands or products at low prices through various methods like direct sourcing or a discount model.
ALDI, another German chain, also ranks high for value (70.4%). Known for its no-frills experience and curated, high-quality house brands at low prices, it has become a popular choice for budget-conscious shoppers seeking quality within their budget. Interestingly, some stores appear on both lists, offering a balance. Wegmans (68.7%), Trader Joe’s (67.2%), and Costco (61.4%) are seen by a significant percentage of their shoppers as providing good value, alongside their praised cheese selections.
Even Sam’s Club (60.1%) and Fred Meyer (59.3%) round out the top value list, proving that different stores appeal to different shoppers’ priorities. Ultimately, whether you’re hunting for a rare imported Gouda or just trying to keep your grocery bill down, knowing which stores excel in cheese quality and which deliver on overall value empowers you to make informed choices.
Navigating the supermarket landscape for cheese and value is a journey with many paths. Some aisles beckon with artisanal delights and expert guidance, promising discoveries that elevate even the humblest cracker. Others offer the thrill of finding surprising quality at prices that leave your wallet feeling a little fuller. By considering what matters most for your next grocery run—be it the quest for a funky flavor bomb or the strategic pursuit of savings—you can transform a routine chore into an exciting expedition, ensuring delicious moments and smart spending one cheese block at a time.
Related posts:
The Best And Worst Grocery Store Chains To Buy Cheese, According To Customers
These Are the 10 Cheapest Grocery Stores in the U.S.
False Facts About Aldi You Thought Were True
