Listen up, I’ll tell you something good. A sandwich is my forever food if chosen. Not just any kind, though; the club sandwich rules above others. Imagine bread, meat, and vegetables piled high like that. Mayo and bacon always provide a bit of magic. It feels simple and classic when done right. Perfection comes when it’s made well. Not all chains make them the same; that’s the truth. So, a mission was naturally born then. I needed to know which chain had the best club. The big names like Subway, Jimmy John’s, and Jersey Mike’s were my picks. I went tasting their clubs, ready to share my thoughts. I gave my thoughts, which were mostly unbiased. The great club sub showdown went like this then.
1. My quest was quite simple, actually. It was to find the best club among sandwich places, that was it. Which chain made the best sub; that’s what mattered most. Pitting these chains against each other was for the taste buds. The author of the first text wanted the same thing, you see. They wanted to know which widely available chain had the ultimate club. It was a truly noble goal, serving others for sure.
2. What makes a club sandwich so great is the key. We need to establish a baseline before eating. What are we even looking for here? A true club needs essential parts, as the text said. Bread, mayo, turkey, lettuce, and tomato are musts. Bacon sometimes comes too, adding extra flavor. Turkey is common, but ham or chicken show up as well.
3. Entering the competition, there were already whispers. Reputations came first before tasting the sandwiches, you see. The author noted early impressions that set the scene. Jimmy John’s bread already had a good name, it seems. The text said the bread was impressive right away. Bread is often overlooked, but it forms the base always. This was a promising signal for Jimmy John’s.
4. My club journey began just like the author’s did. It started at Jersey Mike’s. This chain has a solid reputation since the 1950s. Now, over 2000 shops have popped up everywhere. Ordering their club meant getting it their classic way. Their club includes turkey, ham, provolone, bacon, and mayo. The author added lettuce and tomato as the website picture showed.
5. Jersey Mike’s is known for the amount of meat packed on subs. Reality met expectation, I tell you. The author got their money’s worth with the meat, yes. Turkey and ham were stacked high, about one inch thick. That didn’t count the bacon strips loaded on there. It was a carnivore’s dream, a meat mountain for sure. Beyond the big volume, the quality seemed okay as well.
6. The meat gets the show, but the supporting ingredients are also important. Veggies and condiments balancing the flavors is key. A perfect club needs balanced flavors and textures too. How did Jersey Mike’s do with these parts? The tomato slices on the club were described as being of good size. It’s important that nobody wants thin, sad slices. Good tomatoes add freshness and acidity, cutting through the richness.
7. It wasn’t all sunshine at Jersey Mike’s, okay. Even good sandwiches can have their flaws, you see. The author’s club had issues with the bread and lettuce parts. The wheat bread didn’t feel fresh or soft enough. This was a drawback as the bread is the foundation. A less – than – perfect base hurts the eating experience a lot. Finely chopped lettuce made things worse as well.
8. Despite the bread and lettuce issues, Jersey Mike’s impressed, you see. It impressed most where it counted: the meat mattered. Generous portions and fresh – tasting meat were major pluses. Turkey, ham, and bacon had a fresh taste and good amounts. Mayo balance and tomato slice quality were also good things. Even with minor flaws, the overall feeling stayed positive. The author said they would order it again, 100 percent.
9. **Continuing the Jimmy John’s Journey: Bread and Meat Matters**: The author’s club – sandwich quest moved next to Jimmy John’s. This stop came right after the Jersey Mike’s test. Jimmy John’s also maintains many stores, boasting over 2,000 locations in total. It all began in Illinois sometime during the 1980s. For this particular taste trial, the chosen order was their specific Country Club sub. It listed key items like turkey, ham, provolone cheese, lettuce, tomato, and mayonnaise. The sandwich measured 8 inches and cost $11.97 there. This price was slightly higher than that of the Jersey Mike’s sub.
Where Jimmy John’s truly excels, according to the review, is with its notable bread. The text plainly states that none of the other shops matched the bread quality there. That statement indeed represents high praise from the reviewer’s perspective. Its standard French bread feels just sublime and seems unusually fresh for a place selling fast – food. The author even considered eating it just with butter. This fact shows how great the foundation of that sandwich was.
Beyond the notably stellar bread, the Jimmy John’s club held its own well. While it lacked the bacon punch that Jersey Mike’s version had, the meat and cheese on this one were sliced thicker. Also, the cheese had more flavor, adding another significant layer to the profile. It seemed like Jimmy John’s preferred a completely different focus. Perhaps they emphasized quality and cut instead of sheer volume across everything.
10. **Finishing Strong at Jimmy John’s: Veggies, Mayo, and Overall Vibes**: The veggie component at Jimmy John’s received a positive score as well. The lettuce, despite being chopped, wasn’t minced too fine or too small. This meant it actually remained on top of the sandwich effectively. It didn’t try to make a great escape with every single bite taken. This was a definite improvement over the finely chopped greens found elsewhere. Good, fresh vegetables absolutely make an important difference, you see.
Now, everything wasn’t entirely smooth sailing, though. The author felt there was a bit too much mayo on their particular Country Club sub. If ordered again, they would surely ask for less to get the balance just right. It’s just a minor tweak needed, but it shows how personal a sandwich can feel. This holds true even during a test designed to find the best option, maybe.
But apart from that slight mayo – overload issue, the Jimmy John’s sandwich was deemed pretty much perfect by the reviewer. Coming fresh off the Jersey Mike’s test, which had some bread and lettuce problems before this, Jimmy John’s appeared to nail the base and its key items. It offered an impressive club sub that felt incredibly fresh and well – constructed overall.
11. **Entering the Global Giant’s Arena: Subway**: Finally, the sandwich exploration journey landed at Subway restaurants. This chain stands as the biggest behemoth within the sandwich world overall. Unlike just two other chains, which operate mainly in the US and Canada, Subway is truly a global giant indeed, boasting tens of thousands of stores worldwide. The author admitted they were a previous fan, finding comfort in familiar foods, knowing that it is likely nearby no matter where travel takes them. It’s a different kind of feeling than shops like Jersey Mike’s.
Subway does not offer exact sandwiches called “club” on their regular menus easily. The closest item they have is an oven – roasted turkey alongside a ham choice, maybe. Since Subway lets you play the role of a sandwich maker by choosing your own toppings now, the author customized their order as close to a classic club style as possible. They added mayo, provolone cheese, lettuce, and tomato to the base meats.
Regarding its size and final cost, Subway offered the least budget – friendly choice among the trio. Its standard sub measured 6 inches only, which made it the smallest by a noticeable size compared to others. It also came with the lowest price tag at $8.68 here. Sometimes cheaper things are better for people’s wallets. But in a big showdown about the best club sub here, size and substance often matter quite a bit more than cost savings initially.
12. **Subway’s Take: A Mild Disappointment on Size and Meat**: Sadly, for the author, Subway’s take on a classic club ended up being a mild disappointment. The main reason for this feeling was simply the diminutive size overall. Coming in at only 6 inches, it was the smallest sandwich among the trio. According to the text, it felt very diminutive compared to the other places visited. In a comparison where other chains received praise for their substantial subs, Subway’s smaller size came across as a significant drawback from the reviewer’s opinion.
It was not just about its length, though. The total amount of ingredients packed onto the bread also seemed modest overall. There was not much meat placed on the sandwich itself. Contrast this experience with the Jersey Mike’s test. Their meat stack was an inch thick before adding bacon. The noticeable difference in approach becomes quite clear when comparing. Subway’s typical standard was not built for the meat mountains found elsewhere.
Adding to the feeling of disappointment was the cheese situation. The author’s custom Subway club only came with two pieces of cheese, it seemed. While the other two chains offered generous portions of provolone cheese, Subway felt quite sparse in the overall comparison as felt by the author. When you intensely crave a loaded, classic – type club sub, seeing minimal amounts of key ingredients can certainly dampen the experience greatly.
13. **Subway’s Veggies, Flavor, and Author’s Preference**: The total veggie portions on the Subway club were also described as modest in the text. Unlike the well – appreciated freshly handled veggies found at the other two stops, Subway’s seemed somewhat less impressive than previous ones. This contributed to an overall feeling that the sandwich did not have enough going on visually. A good club sandwich always necessitates a solid ingredient balance. With limited meat, cheese, and veggies, this version struggled to stack up well.
Furthermore, the author felt the meat itself tasted less flavorful compared to others. In a formal taste test focused on finding the best – tasting club – type sandwich, flavor obviously remains of paramount importance throughout the comparison. Compared to the fresh – tasting meats found at Jersey Mike’s and the flavorful cheese with slightly thicker cuts at Jimmy John’s, Subway’s protein seemed to fall short in the taste department notably.
Adding bacon is an available option at Subway places. But it was not on the basic sandwich the author built to copy a club. It would have cost extra as well. Given the overall feeling about the size and ingredient quantities used, the author concluded they would likely stick to their usual Subway orders instead. Trying to make a club here just did not hit the mark effectively.
14. **The Verdict: Jersey Mike’s and Jimmy John’s Take the Crown (Mostly)**: So, after sampling several club subs from these three big players, where did the entire journey ultimately land in the reviewer’s opinion? The author expressed quite clear thoughts on the outcomes. “All three chains had their own way of making a club,” the text states. “But some were better than others, which proved true.” While acknowledging that none of the sandwiches met every single requirement for their ideal club, the ones from Jersey Mike’s and Jimmy John’s came pretty close.
These two specific chains stood out impressively for delivering good substance. Both provided substantial subs loaded with plenty of meat for people. This represents a key factor in a truly satisfying club – type sandwich. Specifically, Jersey Mike’s was noted for having very flavorful meats included. Meanwhile, Jimmy John’s earned top marks by offering the best bread quality, which provided an excellent base and clearly made a strong impression.
In very stark contrast, though, the Subway club the author constructed fell flat entirely. It was smaller and had fewer toppings overall than the others. It also just did not manage to pack much flavor into it. Because of these significant drawbacks noted clearly, the author stated that they likely would not order it again, honestly. Though they would still frequent Subway for their preferred subs choices. It just shows that while Subway is a global giant indeed, its standard offerings may not cut it against focused competitors always.
15. **Peeling Back the Layers: The Business Behind the Subs**: Moving past the author’s personal taste – test results easily, the text offers seriously fascinating insights into these chains’ histories. Particularly, Subway’s recent business operations history is notable. Despite its really massive global footprint, Subway has actually been shrinking its USA presence for nearly a decade now. According to internal company documents seen before, Subway closed a net 631 more stores than it opened in 2024. This continues a trend where the chain shed 7,600 USA restaurants. This trend began since its very peak back in 2015.
To place that large number into a useful perspective for the audience, 7,600 locations equal roughly the entire number of Taco Bell operating locations. It means Subway closed 28% of its USA locations in under ten years! This absolutely massive contraction links back to the context of low unit volumes reported. Essentially, it means each individual Subway store typically does not make much money. Maybe they average less money compared to stores at competitor chains.
While Subway’s average store volumes did reach their highest point ever, in 2024, the average was $490,000 perstore. They still lag significantly behind their closest rivals operation. Jersey Mike’s, for example, boasts average 1.3 million per location, while Firehouse Subs and Jimmy John’s are near the $1 million mark already. Subway’s volumes haven’t kept pace with inflation since 2012. This makes it hard for individual owners to operate profitably. It contributes to the wave of store closures seen, causing the chain to fall in top lists by sales totals.
16. **Size Wars and Public Opinion: More Data Nuggets**: Let us discuss sandwich sizes beyond the author’s personal taste – test feelings. Jersey Mike’s is widely known for its large Giant sub option. Context confirms it is very massive indeed compared to others. Customer and staff estimates place it around 14 to 15 inches in length easily. This Giant sub version measures double the size of their regular 7 to 7.5 – inch sub now. It easily dwarfs their 4 to 5 – inch mini sub options overall. How does this size fact stack up against the competition clearly? Subway’s very famous Footlong sub, despite some issues before, has consistently measured 12 inches since 2015 reports. It still falls short of Jersey Mike’s largest Giant sub option. Other chains like Potbelly (8 – inch BIGS) measure up to 12 inches only. They also don’t quite measure up to Jersey Mike’s biggest option. The only major chain with a bigger standard size option is Jimmy John’s, offering a 16 – inch J.J. Gargantuan choice.
Shifting focus toward public perception about these businesses, YouGov data offers a peek at how Americans view these chains today. When asked who truly makes the best – tasting deli sandwich product, Subway consistently leads, named by 25% of overall Americans surveyed. However, its lead is strongest mainly among younger consumers (35% of those aged 18 – 29). While Jersey Mike’s gains more traction with older customers now (19% of those aged 45 – 64), compared to just 10% of those under 30 liking it. Jersey Mike’s holds steady in second place (17% of the overall data). With Jimmy John’s trailing back in third place (9% score in total). This suggests that while Subway has broad appeal across groups, especially with younger consumers enjoying its convenience factors maybe, older customers seem more likely to favor Jersey Mike’s choices clearly.
The YouGov data also explored why people choose fast food overall. Quality (55%) and Value (48%) rank as the top factors mentioned. But Convenience (47%) and Speed (33%) are crucial too. When rated on these key aspects, it is clearly seen that Jersey Mike’s leads strongly in the Quality metric (with a score of 20 points). This positions it as the clear premium choice among the options available. But Subway pulls ahead significantly in the Value score (13 vs JM’s 7). And utterly dominates in the Speed metric ratings (with a score of 28 vs JM/JJ’s 12). This could help explain its wide popularity everywhere, especially appealing to younger, budget – conscious consumers who value convenience greatly. Despite Jersey Mike’s higher Quality score noted by many, Subway still leads in the Purchase Consideration metrics and Intent to buy, meaning more folks consider Subway and are likely to buy from Subway stores widely, reinforcing its market dominance globally. This holds despite taste test results maybe or unit volume challenges faced by individual stores always.
So, there you have it finally – a deep dive conducted. Exploring club sandwich types from these three big chains reviewed, seasoned with a dose of business reality plus public opinion facts. While the personal taste test crowned Jersey Mike’s and Jimmy John’s as winners noted for their delicious approach to a classic sandwich product, the wider data shows quite a complex picture formed, reflecting market share, customer perception overall, and the sheer massive scale a brand like Subway maintains. It simply goes to show everyone something new: there exists more to a sandwich battle than one bite sometimes.
Related posts:
I tried club sandwiches from Subway, Jimmy John’s, and Jersey Mike’s, and there’s one I wouldn’t order again
Subway closed more restaurants last year
Just How Big Is A Giant Jersey Mike’s Sub?
