The Quintessential Top-Tier Sandwich Chain and 6 Other Passable Options

Few things hit the spot quite like a classic Italian sub. The mix of cured meats, tangy dressings, and robust toppings all nestled inside a perfectly baked loaf of bread is a masterpiece of culinary simplicity. But when your favorite local deli is closed, and the craving hits, where do you go for the next best thing? We’re looking at sandwiches from some of the most well-known chains across the nation to find out which one reigns supreme and which ones are just, well, okay.

After sampling the signature Italian offerings at seven nationwide sandwich chains, we rated them on meat quality, bread texture, topping balance, and bang-for-your-buck value. From regional hits to messy mayo bombs, here’s how these sandwich chains stack up when your cured meat craving strikes.

1. **Potbelly Sandwich Shop**: When it comes to Italian sandwiches, Potbelly reigns supreme. This regional powerhouse has crafted a masterpiece with its Italiano sandwich, which boasts a stunning combination of salami, capicola, mortadella, and pepperoni all in one bite. Few chains can match the depth of flavors provided by those four hearty meats. And let’s talk about the bread—it’s truly top-notch, offering that perfect chew that sandwiches of this caliber demand.

The pièce de résistance here, though, is the giardiniera-style peppers. These tangy, spicy, and slightly crunchy toppings bring a unique flair to the sandwich that other chains simply don’t offer. It’s no wonder this sandwich shines as the chain’s best offering. Potbelly may not be in every city, but if you stumble upon one, it’s worth every mile traveled.

2. **Jersey Mike’s Subs**: A close runner-up, Jersey Mike’s captures the essence of a good Italian sandwich with its signature Mike’s Way preparation. This includes a delightful drizzle of oil and vinegar, paired with an oregano-forward seasoning blend that elevates the sandwich to a whole new level of deliciousness.

The bread, while a bit crumbly, still holds its own, and the overall flavor combination is satisfyingly messy yet irresistible. It’s the kind of sandwich that drips down your fingers and leaves you licking them clean. Add some pickles (pro tip: they’re free), and you’ve got yourself an unforgettable sub experience.

3. **Jimmy John’s**: Jimmy John’s takes a slightly unique approach by sticking to their signature one-big-sandwich-log style, rather than slicing the sub into halves. This quirky presentation might not be for everyone, but the quality of the sandwich itself is undeniable.

The bread has a nice crunch, and the fillings are always fresh. However, the overly maximalist decor in their shops can feel like an assault on the senses, making it more of an in-and-out dining experience. Still, for those who prioritize taste above all else, Jimmy John’s is a solid contender.

4. **Subway**: Subway’s Hotshot Italiano might not be the best Italian sandwich on the market, but it’s certainly reliable. The spicy pepperoni and Genoa salami provide a nice flavor base, and the customizable toppings mean you can create your ideal sandwich every time.

While Subway’s bread isn’t as high-quality as some of the other chains on this list, it gets the job done. Plus, if you’re a fan of Jersey Mike’s Mike’s Way, you can replicate it here with ease. It’s not groundbreaking, but it’s a dependable option that’s widely available.

5. **Firehouse Subs**: If you’re the kind of person who enjoys an adventure with every bite, Firehouse Subs’ Italian offering might be calling your name. But let me warn you in advance—this sandwich is one chaotic feast. Imagine mayo, mustard, Italian dressing, and melted provolone all coming together in a dramatic symphony of flavors. Sounds intriguing, right? But here’s the catch: their bread is oddly thin and struggles to hold everything together, so be prepared for some serious spillage.

What Firehouse gets right is the boldness in flavor, but it’s a sandwich that demands extra napkins (and maybe even a bib). While it’s not the most polished option out there, it’s perfect if you’re in the mood for something a little messy yet satisfying. Just don’t expect it to dethrone the champs on this list.

6. **Quiznos**: Quiznos may not be at the top of everyone’s sandwich bucket list these days, but their Italian sub still deserves a nod. The toasted bread, a signature move for Quiznos, gives the sandwich a lovely crunch that enhances the eating experience. The combination of meats, though not as bold as Potbelly’s, still delivers a decent flavor profile. Toss in some fresh veggies and a drizzle of their zesty dressing, and you’ve got a satisfying bite.

However, it’s not all sunshine and roses. The portion sizes might leave you wanting a bit more, and the meat-to-bread ratio can sometimes feel a little off. Still, if you stumble onto a Quiznos, their Italian sub is worth a try. It’s a nostalgic pick for anyone who misses the chain’s heyday.

7. **Erbert & Gerbert’s**: Rounding out the list is Erbert & Gerbert’s, a lesser-known chain with a quirky name and an Italian sandwich that’s… fine. The bread is decent, the meats are standard, and the toppings are fresh enough. It’s the kind of sandwich you eat, enjoy, and promptly forget about.

Related posts:
6 Italian Subs from Popular Sandwich Chains, Ranked Best to Worst
10 Fast Food Fish Sandwiches, Ranked Worst To Best