Step into the frozen food section, and you’ll find shelves stocked with a variety of convenient, ready-to-eat meals. However, when it comes to frozen seafood, finding the best options requires a bit more exploration. You’ll need a discerning eye to select the highest quality, most flavorful seafood available.
High-quality frozen fish can deliver truly remarkable taste and flavor. Everyone wants a piece of tender fish fillet or fish meat with a crispy texture. This ocean-fresh flavor isn’t just delicious—it also offers exceptional value for your money.
We’ve tried various options. Each product has undergone rigorous testing for taste, texture, and cooking performance. Let’s discover the must-buy list and those that are best left on the shelf.
1. **Great Value Frozen Tilapia**: Fish fillets are a common ingredient in seafood dishes. They are like chicken breast from the sea and have a wide range of uses. Each piece of fish in this product is individually packaged, making meal preparation more convenient. Simply take out the desired portion, thaw without touching the raw fish, and it’s perfectly portioned for one person.
We tried cooking some of the fillets in an air fryer, and the results were satisfying. The thinner edges became crispy, while the thicker parts remained tender and flaky. Tilapia typically doesn’t have a strong fishy odor, which is a plus for those who aren’t fans of seafood. While some may not be fond of tilapia, this product is a healthy alternative.The price is also very affordable, at approximately $6.50 per pound. This is a budget-friendly option for many consumers. It pairs well with almost any dish, including pasta or tacos. It’s not flashy or overly marketed. It simply delivers consistent quality at a reasonable price.
Product on Amazon: Great Value Whole Tilapia, 3 lb (Frozen)
Binding: MP3 Music Product Group: Digital Music Purchase
Price: 9.49 USD
Shopping on Amazon >>
2. **Great Value Wild Caught Skinless Cod Fillets**: We believe that most people prefer individually packaged foods because they are more convenient for meals. However, the cod fillets in the value series are not packaged this way. Although this is only a minor detail, it will affect how you use the frozen blocks. Nevertheless, these cod fillets still have many advantages, such as larger pieces of fish and plump meat, which is indeed excellent.
Nevertheless, compared to other products we’ve tried, they still fall slightly short. If you really don’t care for a strong ocean flavor, cod is usually a good choice, as its taste is generally milder.
In an air fryer test, these fish fillets performed adequately, with tender and slightly chewy meat after cooking. The price is approximately $8 per pound, which seems reasonable. This isn’t a bad product, but others offer better value for money.
3. **Marketside Coho Salmon**: This salmon is a favorite among many. Not only is it delicious, but it is also rich in various health benefits. It is versatile in the kitchen and can be used to make a variety of dishes. However, just like when selecting steak, there can be significant differences in quality. Some cuts are clearly superior to others. Based on our experience, Marketside seems to only sell high-quality products, so you can purchase with confidence.
At first glance, these fish fillets are individually packaged with the skin on and look absolutely stunning. They have a deep pink hue that is visually appealing. When cooked in an air fryer, each bite is exceptionally tender and smooth.The flesh is also very flaky and flavorful, with the classic taste of premium salmon. The skin peels off easily after cooking, which is a great feature. This is typically due to the fat layer in the flesh, which helps lock in moisture.
Salmon is generally more expensive than other fish. The Marketside Coho, priced at nearly $10 per pound, is no exception. Don’t let the price deter you—give this product a try. We believe it’s well worth the cost.
4. **Great Value Wild Caught Pink Salmon**: Here’s a simple fact about food—just because a product is labeled “value” doesn’t mean it’s a good deal, and this principle applies to some frozen seafood products as well. Currently priced at less than $11, this price sounds like a great deal for two pounds, right? The only thing worth praising is that the fish fillets are individually packaged, which is convenient.
From there, the experience goes downhill. The fillets are irregularly sized and oddly shaped. Instead of the typical rectangular shape, they’re small squares. If you’re looking for half a fillet, the value series might satisfy you. Visually, the flesh is pale pink and doesn’t look very appetizing.
Unfortunately, the situation doesn’t improve after cooking. The skin is difficult to peel off, which typically indicates low fat content. The lack of fat results in a bland taste and a lack of richness. This culinary experience is truly disappointing and clearly belongs in the “worst” category.
5. **Great Value Crispy Battered Fish Fillets**: One of the toughest decisions when grocery shopping is whether to go with a big brand or try the supermarket’s own brand to save money. Typically, private-label brands match big brands in quality. Sometimes, supermarket private-label brands can even surprise you with better performance.
Great Value Crispy Battered Fish Fillets demonstrate why choosing a supermarket’s own brand can be a great choice. Each box contains 10 pieces for less than $6, with each fish fillet coated in a uniform, delicate batter for consistent texture.After baking, they turn a golden brown color, looking very appetizing. The batter provides a crispy texture, while the fish inside is tender and flavorful, with no overpowering fishy taste. This creates a perfect contrast with the crispy exterior. The crispy crust pairs well with the fish, which we think is done very well.
We used a few fillets to make fish tacos, and the results were excellent. This product is truly versatile and delicious when enjoyed with tartar sauce. It combines convenience, taste, and value for money, standing out among similar products.Our seafood exploration at Walmart continues. We’re continuing to explore the remaining frozen seafood products. Finding high-value fish products is quite challenging. It requires a thorough understanding of each product. How did the last few perform? The taste test primarily assessed their quality. Are they worth taking up space in your freezer?
6. **Gorton’s Crispy Battered 100% Whole Fish Fillets**: This is a well-known fish brand that offers its own version of crispy coated fish fillets. When compared to the “Value” series, this product is slightly more expensive. You will need to pay approximately seven dollars for ten fish fillets. You may wonder if the extra cost is worth it? Should you choose the brand-name product or the supermarket’s own brand?
Let’s take a look at their appearance and texture after cooking.Gordon’s batter coating is thicker, which affects the appearance and texture after cooking. After baking in the oven, the outer layer has a light, crispy texture. However, there is almost no browning. Most people prefer a golden-brown crust, right? The batter itself is fine, but it has an extremely creamy and salty flavor. This rich batter flavor overpowers the fish itself, which is a real shame.
The fish itself has a decent texture. Compared to Great Value, it’s slightly lighter. In fact, both Great Value and Gorton’s use cod. The fish portion of both brands is essentially the same; it all comes down to the batter and price. However, these factors aren’t enough to make Gorton’s stand out among other products.
Product on Amazon: Gorton’s Parmesan Crusted Fish 100% Whole Fillets, Wild Caught Alaskan Pollock, Frozen, 10 Count, 18.2 Ounce Resealable Bag
Brand: Gorton’s
Binding: Unknown Binding Product Group: Protein
Price: 7.19 USD
Rating: 4.5 Total reviews: 692
Features:
1. Goodness You Can Taste: Bring home a delicious taste of seafood with our Parmesan Crusted Fish Fillets. Made from high-quality, wild-caught Alaskan Pollock, our fillets are ideal for serving up a fresh-tasting, convenient meal.
2. Unmatched Flavor: To lock in our fish’s full flavor and nutrition, we ensure this product is flash-frozen at the peak of freshness. These fillets are coated in real parmesan and sealed in a crunchy, garlic-infused cracker crumb crust.
3. A Wholesome Catch: These fillets are always prepared with no fillers, artificial colors or flavors, hydrogenated oils, or antibiotics. Plus, our fish is a natural source of natural Omega-3s and protein.
4. Easy to Cook: Enjoy a deliciously fresh meal that is prep-free, mess-free, and stress-free! Simply heat fish in a conventional oven until fully cooked, or cook in an air fryer for a crunchier bite.
5. Trusted Since 1849: We’ve served families great seafood for over 170 years because of our longstanding commitment to quality and to ocean preservation. Our Trusted Catch program ensures our seafood is responsibly sourced, made, and packaged*.
Shopping on Amazon >>
7. **Bos’n Rhode Island Calamari Tubes & Tentacles**: It’s time to give squid a try. Squid lovers know just how delicious it can be. Fresh squid dishes from abroad might leave you craving more. But cooking it at home can be intimidating, right?
We decided to give it a try by making a Spanish seafood paella. The preparation process started by chopping the frozen squid into pieces and then sautéing them in olive oil. Though it looked simple, we were still a bit nervous. After all, we had never cooked this ingredient before.
Fortunately, the experience was very positive. In fact, it was much easier to make than we imagined, and our initial concerns were unfounded. The final result was outstanding. Frozen squid can indeed be cooked very well at home, even if you’ve never tried it before. In the Spanish seafood paella, the flavors were perfectly balanced. It didn’t overpower the other ingredients.The price is also quite reasonable. This is a great option for trying new seafood dishes without breaking the bank.
After cooking, the squid had a texture that I initially thought would be a bit chewy since it was mostly frozen. However, it turned out to be quite tender and smooth, not rubbery or tough. The flavor itself has a rich, slightly fishy taste, and if eaten alone, you can really taste the fish.
Finding delicious fish is not just about taste. It is also important to know how to best use these ingredients in your own kitchen. Whether you are looking for quick and easy meals, want to save money, or are interested in exploring new ingredients, these high-quality frozen ingredients will allow you to cook delicious meals at home.
Related posts:
The best fish oil supplements in 2025, tested and reviewed by a dietitian
The Best And Worst Frozen Seafood Items To Buy At Walmart
A Dietician’s Guide to the Best Fish Oil Supplements
