Costco is every bulk-buy enthusiast’s paradise, with unbeatable prices and an amazing array of high-quality frozen options. Among the treasures of the freezer aisle, however, frozen pizzas are the tired and hungry go-to convenience when you just need something, quick, and delicious. Favorito? The Motor City Deep Dish Meat Lovers Pizza is a rich, filling game-changer that’s as good or perhaps even better than any pizzeria. Let’s dive into the best frozen pizzas at Costco and find your new favourite pie.
Not all frozen pizzas are created equal some are flops, while others are total stars that elevate your home pizza game to new heights. We’ve tasted and ranked the biggest winners at Costco to provide you with the ultimate ranking, critiquing crust, toppings, and value. Our goal is to lead you down the freezer aisle with confidence, locating pizzas that will pay off in flavour and satisfaction. Make room in your freezer for these top picks.
This blog is your ultimate guide to Costco’s frozen pizza lineup, packed with tips, tricks, and recommendations to make your next pizza night a hit. From deep-dish delights to gluten-free wonders, we’ve got something for every taste and dietary need. Whether you’re feeding a crowd or enjoying a solo slice, these pizzas will make your evenings easier and tastier. So, grab your cart and let’s explore the pizzas that’ll have your taste buds singing.
1. Motor City Deep Dish: Meat Lover’s Dream
Leading the best-seller list and winning over Costco fans online, Motor City Deep Dish Meat Lovers Pizza (or its Double Pepperoni counterpart) is a Motor City showpiece. This dense, rectangular pan pizza ignores the thin-crust brigade, delivering on a rich, indulgent treat that brings pizzeria action to the home scene. Loaded with pepperoni, sausage, and bacon, it’s a meat aficionado’s dream come true. Reddit fans swoon, calling it “better than delivery” and “some of the best frozen pizza hands down.”
The crust is the star of the show, with crispy edges contrasted by a chewy, airy interior. It is baked in a disposable pan, making prep and clean-up simple no more dishes to deal with. The generous toppings load each morsel with deep flavor, and at roughly $7.50 per pizza or $12.99 for two, it’s a steal for this gourmet flavor. This pizza is a must-try for deep-dish fans seeking a filling meal.
- Meaty goodness: Galore of pepperoni, sausage, and bacon.
- Easy prep: Bakes in its own tray with no-fuss cooking.
- Pro tip: Bake at 425°F for extra crispy edges.
Motor City’s Deep Dish Pizza is a crowd-pleaser that meets all the criteria flavor, texture, and convenience. Feeding a hungry family of mouths or comforting your own cravings, this pie delivers the pizzeria experience without the hefty price tag. Its generous toppings and perfectly balanced crust differentiate it among Costco products. Purchase in bulk and use it as your pizza night favorite. It’s not hard to see why fans won’t quit extolling its virtues this pizza is a home run.
2. Kirkland Supreme Cauliflower Crust: A Gluten-Free Delight
Costco’s Kirkland Signature Supreme Cauliflower Crust Pizza is a standout, always among the top and even the number one for some experts. Perfect for the gluten-free population or just anyone who will give cauliflower crusts a try, this pizza delivers in the taste department. It’s the sole Costco supreme pizza, loaded with pepperoni, sausage, roasted veggies, and a three-cheese blend. It’s a winner that demonstrates healthy does not have to taste bad.
The cauliflower crust is perfectly seasoned, neutral enough to let the toppings shine without an overpowering veggie taste. The toppings are generously portioned and evenly distributed, ensuring a balanced, flavourful bite every time. Priced at $11.99 for two pizzas (about $5.99 each), it’s a fantastic value for a gluten-free option that doesn’t skimp on quality. Shoppers love its crisp edges and rich flavour, with one saying, “I never thought I’d love a cauliflower pizza.”
- Flavourful crust: Harmonious cauliflower base sets off the toppings.
- Hearty toppings: Pepperoni, sausage, vegetables, and cheese.
- Gluten-free win: Perfect for dietary needs without compromise.
This pizza is a winner for anyone seeking a healthier option that still has an indulgent taste. The crust gets it exactly right, delivering the satisfying crunch that will turn even cauliflower sceptics into fans. Its perfectly balanced flavour is a hit with both gluten-free and non-gluten-free pizza lovers alike. Serve it with a crisp salad for a full meal that’s as healthy as it is delicious. It’s testament to how Costco’s freezer section has something for everybody and is a must-keep in your freezer.
3. Ronca din Mushroom & Truffle: Gourmet Treat
For a gourmet option, the Ronca din Mushroom & Truffle Pizza is a high-end champion of Costco’s freezer aisle. Called by reviewers “the bougie Costco pizza,” it has a high-end flavor with garlic sauce, truffle mushroom sauce, and plenty of mushrooms. It’s an odd, unconventional pizza that tastes as if from a high-end restaurant. Reddit fans call it a “10 out of 10” for its rich, meaty flavor.
The crust is more robust but crisps very well, making a great contrast to the rich cheesy toppings. The garlicky sauce, “the most spectacular cream of mushroom soup” in testers’ eyes, adds depth and aroma. While some might have welcomed a stronger truffle flavor, the cheese and mushroom combination is perfect. This pizza is a must for anyone in the mood for something special and different.
- Signature sauce: Truffle and garlic for high-end glamour.
- Crunchy crust: Thick yet perfectly crunchy foundation.
- Kick it up: Drizzle with truffle oil after roasting.
For an added dimension, attempt a sprinkle of Parmesan or red pepper flakes, based on recommendations from Reddit commenters. An air fryer can also deliver restaurant-worthy finish. This is perfect for date nights or if you want to impress guests with less work. Its gourmet flavor and quality are what make it a hit among Costco products. At around $12.99 for two, it’s a gourmet deal that’s well worth every penny for the ultimate pizza night.
4. Kirkland Pepperoni Thin Crust: A Classic Done Right
For thin-crust enthusiasts, Costco’s Kirkland Signature Pepperoni Pizza is a hit, featuring a notch above the simple cheese rendition. In a four-pack, it’s the perfect way to stock up between Costco runs for quick meals. The thick pepperoni slab ensures every bite is full of flavor, and it’s an individual favorite among enthusiasts on Reddit, with one calling it, “There’s actually enough pepperoni to cover the pizza.”
The thin crust provides a satisfying crunch without the cardboard feel of inferior frozen pizzas. The sauce is boldly seasoned, balanced against the gooey cheese and pepperoni without overwhelming them. At $13.69 for four pizzas (around $3.37 per pizza), it’s an affordable option that doesn’t cut corners on quality. This pizza is a go-to for any pepperoni fan.
- Pepperoni galore: Bountiful toppings for robust flavor.
- Crisp crust: Prevents burning with proper baking.
- Excellent value: Four pizzas for several meals.
This pizza is simplicity and consistency in a delicious package, a perfect choice for busy weeknights or spontaneous get-togethers. The thin crust stands up to the test, providing that ideal crunch that complements perfectly with the flavor of the toppings. It’s easy enough to load up with additional veggies or cheese if your creative juices are flowing. At such an amazing price point, it’s a classic that’s hard to beat. Stock up and keep your freezer full and ready for a quick pizza night.
5. Milton’s Cauliflower Crust Veggie: A Healthy Winner
Milton’s Cauliflower Crust Roasted Vegetable Pizza is a winner for diet-conscious, vegetarian-friendly consumers. Its gluten-free cauliflower crust satisfies dietary needs with bold flavor from roasted onions, bell peppers, and zucchini. A combination of mozzarella, Romano, and Parmesan cheese brings a rich, cheesy aspect that makes each bite desirable. It’s a healthier alternative that doesn’t sacrifice taste.
The crust is the highlight here, offering a crunchy texture that can hold up to the dense veggie topping. Redditors are impressed with how versatile it is, noting it’s a good canvas for adding-ons such as pepperoni or hot sauce. For $13.99 for two pizzas (or about $6.95 per pizza), it’s a decent price for a specialty pizza. It’s not low-carb, but it’s perfect for those who desire gluten-free or veggie-focused meals.
- Veggie-packed: Zucchini, peppers, and onions for taste.
- Adjustable: Get your top picks as a spin.
- Gluten-free: For dietary needs without sacrifice.
This is ideal for that person who needs to eat their cake and have it too. The cauliflower crust is an excellent crunch, and the vibrant veggies give it that healthy and fresh vibe. It’s a great substitute for veggie nights or when you want a lighter pizza experience. Serve over a side salad and you’ve got a balanced meal that’s both healthy and delicious. Milton’s proves healthy can taste great and be effortless in Costco’s freezer aisle.
6. Sabatasso’s Gluten-Free Four-Cheese: A Cheesy Victory
Sabatasso’s Gluten-Free Four-Cheese Pizza is a surprise winner that beats the dull reputation of gluten-free items. Perfect for cheese lovers and people with gluten sensitivity, it has a decadent blend of mozzarella, fontina, Parmesan, and asiago. The rice flour crust offers a chewy bite that rivals traditional pizzas. It’s a delicious choice that proves gluten-free doesn’t have to be dull.
The sauce is balanced with a touch of hot, complementing the pungent four-cheese combination. Tasters love its depth of flavor, saying it’s far from a mundane cheese pizza. For $16.99 for three pizzas (about $5.66 each), it’s an excellent value for a fine gluten-free product. This pizza is a must for anybody in search of a cheesy, satisfying meal minus the gluten.
- Cheesy mix: Mozzarella, fontina, Parmesan, and asiago.
- Spicy sauce: Adds a kick to balance out the cheese.
- Great value: A good price for gluten-free quality.
Saba Tasso’s Four-Cheese Pizza is a winner for anyone seeking a decadent, well-flavored pizza that meets dietary needs. With its chewy crust and multidimensional cheese blend, it excels among Costco’s selections, even competing with gluten-based pizzas. It’s perfect for pizza nights when everyone gets to enjoy a slice, whether they’re gluten-free or not. Serve with a light salad to cut the richness. This pizza is evidence that gluten-free need not mean sacrificing taste or quality.
7. DiGiorno Supreme: A Crowd-Pleasing Classic
DiGiorno Hand-Tossed Style Supreme Pizza with Sausage and Pepperoni is a dependable national brand option. Its hand-tossed crust is crisply enough, but chewy enough, providing good support for generous toppings. Drenched in sausage and pepperoni, it’s a supreme pizza staple. It’s a favorite of those who desire a comforting, satisfying meal.
The ample toppings create a rich, meaty flavor in every bite, and it’s a party pleaser for family nights or gatherings. It may not be quite as handcrafted as some of the specialty pizzas, but it’s always reliable. For $13.61 for three pizzas (about $4.54 per pizza), it’s a budget-friendly option that delivers on taste. DiGiorno is a favorite for easy, dependable pizza nights.
- Thick toppings: Pepperoni and sausage for deep flavor.
- Even crust: Crisp but chewy for optimal texture.
- Great value: Three pizzas for several meals.
This pizza is all about having great pizza taste with minimal work. Its reliability makes it a great choice for busy families or last-minute party. You can kick it up a notch with added toppings if you’re creative, but it’s good on its own. For this price, it’s a staple in the freezer in any pizza lover’s household. DiGiorno proves that sometimes a classic done well is all anyone needs for a great meal.
8. Kirkland Cheese Pizza: A Canvas of Choice
Other occasions call for less, and Costco’s Kirkland Signature Cheese Pizza is the evidence. Four-pack priced, this budget-friendly pie is a blank slate waiting for its masterpiece for pizza lovers who like to customize. Some might find it “dull,” but its crunchy crust and flavourful sauce make for a decent base. At $11.59 for four pizzas (approximately $2.90 per pizza), it’s a value for on-the-go meals.
The crust crisps to perfection when cooked on a pan, and the cheese melts to perfection for an old-fashioned pizza experience. Redditors suggest topping it with BBQ chicken, basil, or pineapple to add your own touch. Its power is its versatility, making an ordinary pie extraordinary. Such a pizza is perfect for free-spirited cooks or for those who love a plain cheese pizza.
- Personalize: Top with your favourite toppings for a variation.
- Crunchy crust: Pan-bake to avoid burning.
- Affordable: Four pizzas for best value.
This cheese pizza is an excellent option for weeknights when you’re short on time and want to eat affordably. Its simplicity makes it ideal for kids or picky eaters, and its personalizable nature lets you play with flavors. The low cost means you can buy in bulk and not go broke. Top with a salad or garlic bread and you have an entire meal. Kirkland’s Cheese Pizza is a corner stone that’s ready to be a star in your kitchen at all moments.
9. Bellatrix Sausage Italia: A Sausage Lover’s Favorite
For those that enjoy sausage, the Bellatoria Sausage Italia Pizza is the standout among Costco’s frozen options. This thin crust pizza comes in a three-pack and has an overwhelming, sausage-rich flavor that can’t be beat. Its fans on Reddit classify it as one of the best frozen pizzas, not just at Costco but anywhere. It’s perfect for those who enjoy a salty, savory bite.
The generous sausage topping is the centrepiece, giving a rich, meaty taste with every bite. The extremely thin crust gives a light crunch to let the sausage take centre stage without smacking the palate. For around $12.99 for three pizzas (or roughly $4.33 per pizza), it’s a steal for a specialty pie. This pizza is a must-buy for sausage lovers looking for a quick, delicious meal.
- Sausage focus: Powerful meaty flavour in every bite.
- Thin crust: Delicate crunch to add to toppings.
- Salty punch: Perfect for customers who like bold Flavors.
Bilateria’s Sausage Italia Pizza is a champion among customers who crave a bold, Savory flavour in their pizza. Its thin crust and generous sausage win over customers, especially those who like a saltier flavour profile. Serve it with a light side dish to counteract the richness, or serve it straight up for a satisfying dinner. It’s a great option for pizza nights if you want something tasty and easy. Keep a pack on hand for a quick, sausage-stuffed snack.
10. Amnon’s Kosher Regular: Authentic New York Style
Amnon’s New York Select Kosher Regular Pizza is a game-changer when it comes to those looking for a kosher choice that won’t cut corners on flavour. This two-pack brings the real New York-style pizza experience with a handmade, oven-baked crust. It’s an unusual find in the frozen food section, meeting individual dietary requirements with quality and tradition. According to Reddit users, it appears like “real NY-style pizza,” and they are correct.
The crust is the embodiment of the quintessential New York slice, just the right balance of chew and crunch. The cheese and sauce are perfectly balanced, with an old-world flavour that will appeal to pizza fundamentalists. At around $12.99 for two pizzas (about $6.50 per pizza), it’s a decent value for a specialty kosher pizza. This pizza is a must for anyone seeking an authentic, kosher-friendly meal.
- NY-style crust: Handmade for authentic texture.
- Kosher-friendly: Meets specific dietary needs.
- Classic flavour: Balanced sauce and cheese.
Amnon’s Kosher Pizza puts it all together, food restrictions and taste, for a genuine New York-style experience. Its classic Flavors and homemade crust differentiate it for kosher consumers and pizza enthusiasts alike. Perfect for family nights or celebrations, it’s a reliable option that won’t disappoint on flavour. Add a light salad to round out the meal. This pizza is evidence that Costco’s freezer section has something for everybody when it comes to taste and quality.
11. Saba Tasso’s French Bread Pepperoni: A Quick Snack
Saba Tasso’s French Bread Pepperoni Pizza has a unique twist with a baguette-shaped crust, perfect for hectic dinner or snack time. Pizzas individually cook in under 10 minutes using a microwave-and-oven combination, qualifying them as a busy day savior. The pepperoni is good, but the cheese can be more potent. It’s a convenient option for individual dinners or group snacks.
The crust of French bread provides a hearty, lightly heavy chunk that differs from typical pies. For $12.49 in a 9-pack (approximately $1.39 a pizza), it’s a budget meal for on-the-go eating. Not fancy, but does the job with convenience and flavor for the cost. Reddit enthusiasts like its snack value and speedy preparation.
- Rapid prep: Ready in under 10 minutes.
- alternative crust: French bread for a change.
- inexpensive: Fine value for servings.
It’s perfect for after-school snacks, quick lunch, or feeding a crowd without having to cut it up. The French bread crust is a welcome departure, and the low price point makes it a no-brainer to buy in bulk. It won’t compete with gourmet options, but it can’t be beat in busy households for convenience. Air fry it for a crunchier texture. Saba Tasso’s French Bread Pizza is a convenient, tasty addition to your freezer.
12. Saba Tasso’s Mini Singles: Perfect for Children and Snacks
Sabatasso’s Mini Singles are the best convenience pizza, perfect for a kid’s lunch or last-minute snack. Coming in a 12-pack cheese and pepperoni, these little pies bake in minutes. For $10.49 per box (around $0.87 each), they’re an affordable choice for busy families. They’re not fancy, but they’re great for what they’re meant for.
The crust has a floured border that becomes lovely crisper, and the cheese blend of mozzarella, cheddar, Parmesan, and provolone adds surprising richness. The sauce is spicy sweet enough, and these minis turn out quite Savory. Reddit reviewers praise their snackability, especially when air-fried to become crispy. They’re ideal for a quick gathering or emergency meal.
- Kid-friendly: Ideal size for small appetites.
- Rapid cooking: Great in an air fryer or oven.
- Heavily discounted: Under $1 per pizza.
These little pizzas are a lifesaver for busy parents or anyone needing a quick, no-fuss meal. Small and budget-friendly, they’re perfect for children, snacks, or sudden gatherings. The cheese blend and sauce balance them beyond average mini pizzas. Sprinkle herbs for an added kick of flavour. Saba Tasso’s Mini Singles are a tasty, convenient addition to any freezer for those times when convenience is paramount.
