Trader Joe’s freezer aisle is a joy to wander through if you’re a fan of delicious things to eat. The thriving store, which has carts filled to the brim and busy customers, only intensifies the excitement of finding their legendary ice creams. These aren’t just pints they’re cult favorites that spark debates and inspire devotion. The frozen desserts that come from typical to vibrant and even bizarre, flavor combinations are all Trader Joe’s inventions. The result is 14 must-have ice cream that got shoppers out of their homes and back into the freezer section, gathered together under one roof of the best potluck treats
What adds to the character of these sweet treats? The combination is just right with fine ingredients, fun flavor combinations and your texture of the dish. The taste testing crew raves about the texture of the cream, the harmonious flavors, and the mix-ins that can be both one of the inspirations for the so-called crave-bites or just simply add a crunchy texture, to name every bite eaten. Regardless if you like ice cream pure and plain or prefer to go wild with your taste buds, pints are available for you. I found myself with three pints in my cart on my last Trader Joe’s ice cream adventure. Let’s do this together by sampling some of the stunning frozen gems that make every lick a joy.
This line-up is the result of the voting-they are all the things that show that Trader Joe’s ice cream is the best. The range from “super premium” richness to non-dairy is made to surprise and delight the consumer with every scoop. These are inexpensive, creative and, thus, suitable for any moment, from watching movies alone with drinks made at home to having a party with desserts. Prepare to get to know your new freezer favorites one by one. There are many reasons why you should not only contribute to the hype by way of these star ice creams but also allocate space in your cart for them
1. Coffee Bean Blast IceCream
Coffee Bean Blast Ice Cream is any coffee aficionado’s dream come true, boasting a powerful full-bodied taste that’s liquid dynamite by the pint. Ground and brewed French Roast coffee beans and Colombian coffee are the menu ingredients, so this one’s one “super premium” big gun that blends bitter, sweet, and strong emotions. This is big-baller rich decadent ice cream for coffee connoisseurs. My tasting was prompted by one clear fan’s review rave, but from the first bite, I was anointed the same fanboy.
- Strong Taste: Grounds and brewed coffee contain strong taste.
- Creamy Texture: Thick and heavy, not a slosh of coffee.
- Multi-Purpose Ingredient: Delicious alone or as an accompaniment for chocolate cake.
Whereas all the other coffee ice creams are one with the creaminess, this one keeps the coffee bold and triumphant. The rich butter base underlies the bold taste so that the scoop is addictive. The ultimate late night treat or morning euphoric boost (no guilt!). The winner by a hair for overall boldness from all our tastings was this virtually black stunner. If you drink black coffee, you’ll want blacker ice cream–then you’ll have to have this one.
By our fellow contributor to this potluck, we couldn’t help but steal spoons. Decadent enough to share but not possible to resist hoarding. Enjoy with a brownie for an over-the-top dessert, or from the pint. Coffee Bean Blast is the lifesaver for dessert enthusiasts. Stock up before all gone from the stores
2. Horchata Ice Cream
Horchata Ice Cream is one holiday star that brings the Latin soul to your spoon, capturing first spots in taste comparisons. The ice cream is influenced by the traditional cinnamon-rice drink, an-rich base accompanied by brown rice flour, the sea’s promise, sea salt, and crushed horchata cookies for textural bite. The strong kick from the cinnamon is strong but well in hand, never cloying. I poched up a pint one summer, and it was utterly blissful!
The flavor is strong cinnamon, boosted by chunks of tender cookie giving good textural enjoyment. It’s smooth, creamy, and sweet enough, so this one stands out for the lovers of spice. Perfect for cozy nights or the holiday season, this is one crowd-pleaser that gets exotic. The cookies elevate this way past average cinnamon ice cream. Don’t pass on this seasonal goodie as it goes fast!
- Spicy Sweet: The cinnamon sparkles with an unachievable balance.
- Textural Triumph: The horchata cookies are good and crunchy.
- Seasonal Frenzy: A short-term delicacy you must have.
The fam was over the last scoop from this one during our bbq the end. The flavor is one of the reasons why this is the talker ice cream, and the creaminess gets the work done. Share this ice cream with churros for the holiday vibe, or on its own. Horchata Ice Cream is the must-have for the brave. Don’t miss out on the buzz this summer
3. Mint Chip Ice Cream
Trader Joe’s Mint Chip Ice Cream convinces the doubters with the bright, all-natural taste. Peppermint extract, cream, and egg yolks compose this one, waiting until the end to bring on the artificial green food dye so the base is chilly, bright white. The chocolate fudge chips contribute the hard, bitter bite that pushes each bite from good to great. Never been much of a mint enthusiast before this pint.
- New Mint: Peppermint extract provides a pungent, vigorous flavor.
- Crunchy Chips: Chocolate fudge delivers perfect texture.
- Balanced Bliss: A refreshing but rich scoop.
The base is richest-smoothing creamiest, peppermint lifting up without overpowers. Chocolate chips and vanilla provide warming satisfactions to the mint’s cold. It’s suitable for warm weather or an aftersupper refreshing the taste buds. Even mint antagonists will be able to abide by this “surprising tolerable.” The classic done right, this is sure to convince any crowd.
Our mint chip aficionado couldn’t help but be swayed by the bright flavor of this scoop. It’s an honored permanent freezer resident for spontaneous dessert evenings. Try hot fudge on top for an decadentric treat, or straight up. The Mint Chip Ice Cream is the ultimate refreshing must. Grab a pint and why this is the fan favorite
4. Wildberry Cheesecake Ice Cream
Cheesecake Ice Cream is one crazy wildberry-flavored indulgent treat that brings together sweet cream and raspberry, strawberry, and blackberry purées. Actual chunks of cheesecake are swirled in so that each bite is one tangy, creamy pleasure. It’s the ultimate “super premium” pint that is dessert heaven. My party guests took one glance at this and devoured the whole thing before the rest of us even had seconds
The berry swirl boosts the tang, the cheesecake chunks provide full, dreamy taste. It’s well-balanced not too sweet, not too dense and richly textured. Perfect for warm-season parties or slow evenings, this’s an all-around crowd-pleaser. The mix-ins make each scoop an event and delicious. The pint’s one of the test’s best regardless of what.
- Gooey Mix-Ins: The star-studded pieces are chees.
- Tart-Sweet Balance: Peaches are well-paired by cream.
- Creamy Dream: Smooth Silkeness Elevates Each Bite.
Sis proclaimed this was her “new obsession” after one bite. Share-worthy (or not!) and delightful with fresh berries or an apple crumble. The bright flavors make this the star of the show anytime. Fruit enthusiasts, dessert enthusiasts – you must try the Wildberry Cheesecake. Order yours before they’re all gone
5. Strawberry Ice Cream
Trader Joe’s Strawberry Ice Cream redo’s the classic with the good stuff – the real strawberries for an in-your-face, all-natural flavor. Unlike fake grocery-store imitators, this pint serves up a bright, clean flavor with the real pieces of fruit. It’s sweet, but not cloyingly so, nicely balanced without over-cloying. My husband tasted it out of the blue, but we’re making it our new warm-weather favorite
The foundation, consisting of cream, egg yolks, and sugar, is reinforced with fruit juice to get the robust pink color. Each bite is tasting as if you’re biting into an overripe strawberry, with pieces adding body. Good for sundaes, cones, or out of the pint. That’s the way strawberry is done, better even than the name brands. It’s an old-school flavor with excellent execution.
These vanished on our most recent picnic with the kids, but even the pickiest eaters adored them. All-natural taste makes this an all-age hit, and whipped cream is the ultimate accompaniment. It’s refreshing but decadent, the ultimate good-weather dessert. Strawberry Ice Cream is an all-time classic you have to try. Try one by the pint
6. Chocolate Non-Dairy Frozen Dessert
Chocolate Non-Dairy Frozen Dessert made from coconut milk is the champion for us dairy-free dessert enthusiasts. The pint is surprisingly velvet-smooth, with the density of a mousse that is on the same caliber as the classic ice cream. The cocoa taste is deep and fulfilling, not icy norWatery. My vegan pal tried some alongside me, and we were both amazed!
- Creamy Surprise: The coconut milk keeps this very creamy.
- Rich Cocoa: All-natural all-chocolate flavor, dairy.
- Diet-Compatible: Suitable for lactose-intolerant or vegan diets.
While the majority of standard-non dairy versions are thick, the heavy whipped feeling is absent with this dessert, rather tasting fluffy, rich, but with no compromise on flavor. Ideal for sundaas or scoop-only, good for all dessert enthusiasts. The coconut milk base has an undertow sweetness that overpowers the chocolate. It’s tribute to Trader Joe’s universality inventions. The pint is proof dairy-free is decadently yummy.
My skeptic dairy-free cousin couldn’t believe how good this was. It’s our permanent fixture during our family functions so everyone gets to have some. Enjoy with fresh cut fruit as an alternative, or enjoy straight. Chocolate Non-Dairy is an absolute must for inclusive dessert tables. Try it out and indulge the new favorite
7. Black Tea and Boba Non-Dairy Frozen Dessert
Black Tea and Boba Non-Dairy Frozen Dessert injects the freezer with the essence of bubble tea, an herbal, bitter tea taste. Gummy boba bubbles offer the sudden sweetness of mixed texture. Less decadent than dairy pints but loaded with novel flavor. Me took this hot afternoon, and the outcome was a sweet find
The coconut milk foundation is rich with black tea flavor, balanced by the rubbery gummy boba eyeballs. There is no syrupy sweetness, concluding with a high-end finish for dessert lovers. Tea lovers or one that is eager for something different will know that this is the strong version. Trader Joe’s nails this pint by combining innovative non-dairy desserts. It’s an experiment that’s worth trying for fearless taste buds.
- Typical Flavor Profile: Chewy boba seeds and earthy tea.
- Light Dessert: Light enough, good for hot weather.
- Vegan-Friendly: Coconut milk base suits diverse diets.
It was presented to one book group by one’s partner where the whole group had the discussion. Good to share or as an all-around drink, with great lingering flavor. Try with a delicate cake to have contrast, or by itself. Off-beat Black Tea and Boba is a delightful discovery. Try for an exotic dessert adventure
8. French Vanilla Ice Cream
French Vanilla Ice Cream is the ultimate proof that less is better, since the good is never dominating. The custard-dense base is made from egg yolks, cream, and vanilla. This “super premium” is extremely versatile and extremely smooth. It is the ultimate companion to pies, cookies, or by itself. I had mine with apple pie, but this was a match made in heaven!
The light vanilla taste and velvet-like mouthfeel constitute an all-time favorite that is great just the way it is. It is not overbearing, but the richness comes out where you are treated with sweets or sprinkles. Good for any family function or any casual night out, the crowd is all ages. The product is Trader Joe’s take on classic flavors. This is the classic reliable for any dessert function.
My grandma vanilla purist fell head over heels for this as her ultimate favorite on the very first bite. It’s great to serve next to heavy desserts or scoop straight out of the pint. The velvety texture will make any scoop enjoyable, and sharing is easy too. French Vanilla is an ingredient must-have among classic dessert fanatics. Keep on hand for versatility
9. Ultra Chocolate Ice Cream
Chocolate Ice Cream Ultra is the fantasy of the chocoholic, boasting an exceptionally strong but well-rounded taste that’s never sticky. Blended with cream, cocoa, and egg yolks, this’s a “super premium” pint boasting an exceptionally shop-quality smooth mouthfeel. Good-natured but great, this one’s got all the points exactly right. Mine had post-dinner, and the finish was pure chocolate nirvana
- Pure Chocolate: Natural cocoa radiates without syrupy sweetness.
- Silky Consistency: Thick and decadent, like an.archive scoop shop.
- Versatile Side Dish: Delicious by itself or with berries for contrast.
The hint of bitterness from the cocoa blends with an equal, velvet-rich base so you’re happy bite after happy bite. The best for sundaes, milkshakes, or outta-the-pint consumption. This pint gets traditional chocolate ice cream without getting over the top. That’s the default for any chocolate craving. Trader Joe’s does minimally with this one.
It is stocked by my chocoholic brother in the freezer constantly. Enjoy this during TV nights or by yourself. Savor this topped with whipped cream for the most indulgent treat, or enjoy this the classic way. Ultra Chocolate is the ultimate for the hard-core chocoholic. Scoop this up and indulge
10. Speculoos Cookie Butter Ice Cream
Speculoos Cookie Butter Ice Cream is the most decadent treat that makes one popular spread an ice cream. Composed of Midwest cream and chunks of cookie with warm-spice seasoning, this “super premium” pint is buttery and nostalgalic. The small pieces and the big pieces of cookies make the product have good bite. My party lasted for minutes when this was presented.
The butterscotch-flavored base is studded with crushed Speculoos cookies for textural punch. Rich but well-balanced, good for cookie aficionados craving decadence. Good for dessert tables or by-the-pint scooping, this one is attention-grabber but crowd-pleaser. This pint is one example where Trader Joe’s redoes takeouts. Give this one a try if you’re crazy about cookie butter!
My colleague went crazy over this product after trying some, and she makes sure she’s well-stocked with this as her treat du jour. The pieces of cookie make the bite spicy, but the base is all warmth and comfort. Try this with a hot brownie for an out-of-this-world treat. Speculoos Cookie Butter Ice Cream is the unabashedly decadent winner. Try scoring a pint and become a fan
11. Dulce De Leche Ice Cream
Dulce De Leche Ice Cream is the caramel aficionado’s dream come true, with swirls of buttery, caramel-flavored glory. The “super premium” foundation is extremely, extremely smooth, topped off with lavish dulce de leche for the ultimate finish. Sticky, sweet, decadent but never cloying. Popped this one the other evening straight outta work, and that was indulgent comfort food in a pint
- Rich Swirls: Caramelized dulce de leche tips each scoop over.
- Creamy Bliss: Extremely thick, velvet-like texture for ultimate decadence.
Good all by itself, or with apple pie.
The caramel flavor hugs the cream base to form an even, rich treat you won’t be able to set aside. Perfect for cold evenings or party distribution, enjoy with all the sweet tooth lovers. The creaminess keeps the bite melt away from your mouth. This is the standout among caramel fanatics. Trader Joe gets this rich, warm flavor exactly right
Sister hoarded this pint by the first bite and she justified its addictiveness. Good with fruit or a pinch of sea salt for an extra kick. The rich quality makes this good for special occasions, but good also for casual treats. Dulce de Leche Ice Cream is the ultimate treat. Scoop out for sweet escapes
12. Fudgy Cookie Dough Ice Cream
Fudgy Cookie Dough Ice Cream is “super-premium” cookie dough-studded ice cream with fudge centers. The vanilla is decadantly deep and creamy with chocolate chip dough centers and sea salt fudge. A “super premium” pint that’s like getting one big hug per scoop. We had this out during movie night, and everyone loved this!
The liberal mix-ins make each bite full-flavored and bite-y, from fudgy to chewy. Kid-friendly, take-and-bye-by-adult-friendly, take it out to the weekend party or enjoy by oneself. The salty fudge is matched by the sweet vanilla so wonderfully-the ultimate perfection. The crowd-pleaser never fell short. It’s decadence done the Trader Joe’s way.
These kids pester me for this each Saturday, and I don’t blame them–it’s addictive! Savor with a warm cookie for an over-the-top dessert, or scoop straight from the pint. The packed flavor makes it the ultimate party star. Try our Fudgy Cookie Dough Ice Cream. Get some for immediate dessert nirvana
13. Ube Ice Cream
Ube Ice Cream is the latest seasonality to bring Filipino purple yam swag to the freezer case. Boo is sweet nutty flavor with bright complexion, this is one beauty for the eyes. The base is the creamy even-keel type that ain’t too strenuous. Brought this home during the summer restock, and this was one tasty escapade!
- Dramatic Appearance: Stunning purple hue makes everyone silent.
- Distinctive Taste: Sweet, nutty, hint coconut.
- Seasonal Scarcity: One-time enjoyment well worth the quest.
The custard-rich body is paired with an onion-like, vanilla-like flavor making this dessert choice refined. Enjoy this confection with party guests or by itself for an exotic delight. The refined sweetness will tantalize adventurous eaters and curious palates. Trader Joe’s worldliness is revealed with the Ube Ice Cream. Don’t miss out on this red orchid-like gem when you spot it coming to the stores!
Introduced to me as an ube by myαλύτεfriendsö this pint, I’m hooked. It’s the party talk everyone’s had, an exotic crowd-pleaser taste. Accompanied by fluffy cake to complement, or straight up. Pinoys are crazy for the ube-flavored kind of this popular ice cream. Get it first before someone else does
14. Take Lemons from Life and Make Ice Cream
When Life Gives You Lemons Make Ice Cream is one citrus-flavored seasonal treat that cheers up the day. The lemon juice, zest, and shortbread cookie pieces meld together in an ice cream base for the ultimate tart-sweet flavor. It’s bright, cheerful, and all-naturally yellow without the brighteners. I was lucky enough to try this come springtime, and boy, was it the zesty revolutionizer
The tartness of lemon pairs well with the buttery shortbread for the ultimate pair of tart and sinful flavors. The ultimate warm weather dessert or cool interlude following a heavy meal. The airy composition makes the decadence continuous but keeps everyone feeling refreshed.
This short-season pint is everyone’s favorite for good reason. Trader Joe’s perfected this citrus dropsey! We adore this during our Easter brunch–the crowd-pleaser with pizzazz. Try with berries for an offseason twist, or by itself for an out-and-out refreshing kick. The shortbread adds the ultimate crunch that makes each scoop all the better. Try our Lemon Ice Cream come-season! Stock up when you see it coming
