New York City bursts with life and amazing food. It holds so much energy and history, too. Eight million folks call the five boroughs home. About 25,000 places keep them fed—an astonishing number, really. Food defines this city just like Lady Liberty or Broadway’s bright lights. Choices feel endless, from fancy dinners you book months in advance to noodle shops in Queens.
Navigating the vibrant food scene sometimes gives you a price shock. New York does offer quality dining at any cost, though, which makes it stand out. Yet some famous foods and restaurants cost a lot. Lately, one legendary sandwich online started a big debate. Folks wondered if paying that price is truly okay.
We talk about Katz’s Delicatessen; it stands as a real New York icon. Lately, it has faced online criticism about the cost of its famous sandwich. A post praising the ingredients began the trouble by mistake. It quickly grew into a large controversy. Viewers called the nearly $30 price tag something bad. It was labeled “diabolical” and even “a waste of money.” Seems even in a pricy city like New York, some costs are just harder to handle. Let’s look closely at this tasty but costly debate.
1. **Katz’s Delicatessen: A NYC Institution**: Katz’s Delicatessen started way back in 1888. It holds a special place in the hearts of many here in New York and for visitors. It’s located on the Lower East Side, an area that respects history but also has new food places. Katz’s remains the oldest deli of its kind in the city of New York. More than just a place to eat, it takes you back in time. It represents a bit of living history from the past.
This part of downtown Manhattan, the Lower East Side, is home to spots that tourists love. Katz’s Deli and Russ & Daughters are examples; both continue to thrive. Their success alongside newer places keeps the neighborhood relevant for dining. Katz’s, with its long history and constant fame, is a good example. It shows that a classic New York place still matters today.
Taste Atlas recently called the deli a venerated New York City institution. It was named the most legendary restaurant in the Big Apple. Not only that, but it also ranked as the eighth most iconic eatery in the world. This kind of global recognition confirms its status as a must-see place. Maybe this helps explain the price associated with eating there.
2. **The Infamous $30 Sandwich: The Price Point**: The recent online drama really focused on one thing. It wasn’t just any dish but Katz’s very famous sandwich. An X post first liked the sandwich a lot. It accidentally began the fight by saying $27 was the cost. But the sandwich shown, that looks like a Reuben. It actually sells for just a little more at $29.95. That is before changing anything on it. The super famous pastrami sandwich, another top pick costs $28.95 there.
This cost, hovering right around $30, caused the internet to explode. In a city perceived as costly by everyone, a single sandwich hitting this price stirred reactions. It became a popular talking point for many online. It sparked wide discussions on value, what people expect, and food costs here. It’s part of the city’s pricing landscape.
The argument wasn’t just about the number; it seemed to be about what that price meant to those arguing. For some, it seemed too high, totally exorbitant. They compared it to sandwiches in other places. For example, in Albania, they apparently sell for 1to6. The discussion quickly went beyond just the cost itself. It questioned whether any sandwich could command such a high price, regardless of how famous or well-made it is.
3. **Online Outrage: “Diabolical” and “Waste of Money”**: The reaction on X, that social media platform, came fast and was often harsh. Many users openly showed their dislike for the price. They used strong words to express their disbelief and disapproval. Comments called the sandwich “diabolical” and a “waste of money.” It was declared “highway robbery” for the reported $27 cost.
The huge amount of negative comments showed that many people online felt the price was unreasonable. A critic sadly said, “Such a waste of food and money.” They added, “How can you not feel sick to your stomach halfway through?” Another person simply stated, “$27 is highway robbery. What a rip-off…” Clearly, for those people, the value they perceived did not match the cost at all.
Some criticisms went even further regarding the size of the sandwich. They questioned whether such a large portion at that cost was necessary. One user joked, “Half the ingredients, half the price, please.” He added, “No one is eating a small animal and a bag of cheese between two pieces of bread, lol.” Others simply dismissed Katz’s altogether, calling it “really overrated and a total tourist trap” for visitors. They suggested that a “neighborhood bodega” offered better food at a third of the price. The internet crowd seemed mostly unhappy about this price.
4. **The Reuben vs. Pastrami: What $30 Gets You**: It is true that online talk focused generally on the price. But the sandwich that sparked the debate in that first post looked like Katz’s Reuben. Please note that this specific sandwich actually costs $29.95 before substitutions. It must be said that it represents a substantial meal creation. It has several layers of tasty corned beef or pastrami inside.
Traditionally, the Reuben is always stacked tall. It contains sauerkraut, Swiss cheese, and Russian dressing. All of this is placed between two large slices of rye bread. It certainly makes a big meal. It’s a true New York classic, made with generous portions. The argument around the price questions whether the quantity and quality of these ingredients, when combined in this traditional way, truly justify the cost.
Beyond the Reuben, Katz’s very famous pastrami sandwich costs $28.95. Many argue that this is perhaps the deli’s most well-known food item. Both sandwiches are classic and showcase what the classic New York deli experience is like at Katz’s. The high price is mostly for these signature dishes. This means that the argument about value aligns with the main offerings on Katz’s menu.
5. **The “When Harry Met Sally” Legacy: Cultural Fame**: Katz’s place in popular culture contributes to its fame. It might also help explain its pricing, you see. It played an unforgettable role in the 1989 movie “When Harry Met Sally.” The deli became the setting for the film’s famous orgasm scene. This moment has been discussed and celebrated for many decades now.
This movie scene made Katz’s a destination that people want to visit. It attracts film fans and tourists from everywhere. People visit because they want to reenact a well-known scene. They want to experience the place’s atmosphere. This cultural value adds something to dining here. To be honest, it’s more than just the food itself. It adds to the idea that you’re paying for the sandwich and the opportunity. This is dining, perhaps, in a location of historical and cultural significance.
The enduring fame from the film means Katz’s remains in the public eye. It is always on the list of must-visit New York places. This constant presence is associated with a beloved movie moment. This truly influences its status as a travel destination. It may allow it to charge prices that reflect this special cultural value. Putting a price on movie history is difficult, it seems.
Product on Amazon: When Harry Met Sally – Movie Poster – 11 x 17
Brand: Punt Dog Posters
Binding: Unknown Binding Product Group: Home
Price: 10.99 USD
Features:
1. Add this spectacular poster to your collection today!
2. This poster measures approx. 11 x 17.
3. Brand new and expertly rolled and shipped.
4. This poster is from When Harry Met Sally (1989)
Shopping on Amazon >>
6. **Defending the Price: The “Experience” and “Quality”**: Lots of people online did not like the price, but many customers defended Katz’s as well. New Yorkers living here argued that the price was acceptable. Their points often mentioned aspects of the dining experience that you can’t quantify. They also talked about how well the food was prepared. For these supporters, the cost meant more than just the sandwich itself.
Jake Hughes from the Lower East Side put this view clearly. He said “I mean, it’s New York. Everything’s expensive here.” He added “You pay for the experience, you pay for the name itself. Plus the quality, plus New York too”. This idea stresses the price covers everything. It includes the feeling, history, what people say and where you are in New York. He even thought it was better than spending $45 for two burgers and fries at Shake Shack. He suggested splitting a $30 Katz’s sandwich was better he feels.
Other people defending the deli only talked about the quality of the meat. Tim Brierley, who lives on the Upper East Side, passionately called it “the best f – – king pastrami on planet Earth.” He simply stated, “I always pay the price for it.” Similarly, Tami McCarthy, a resident of NYC, felt it was an “iconic New York experience that I actually consider priceless.” It was something you wouldn’t do every day but was perfect for a “special occasion.” She felt it had “that taste of New York that I’m all about.” These voices show that for many, the quality and the special experience make the price acceptable to them.
7. **The Meat Preparation: Weeks of Curing**: A main point used by people who like Katz’s is the meat preparation. This is likely why it costs so much. Fans defending the price often mention how much work goes into making the pastrami and corned beef there. They say the meat takes weeks to cure.
People who support the deli explain that the meat is “cured for weeks in a saltwater brine.” This long curing process is necessary to achieve the taste and texture that Katz’s is widely known for. After it cures, the meat is then reportedly boiled and steamed. This makes it even softer and ready to be sliced by hand.
Finally, workers slice the meat carefully, one piece at a time, by hand. This manual method requires skill and precision. It is part of the traditional way of doing things there. It contributes to the quality of the final food product in the sandwiches. This preparation, which takes weeks of curing and careful work, is shown as a major reason for the higher cost compared to sandwich places that do less traditional work.
8. **Comparing Deli Prices: Not Just Katz’s**: Most of the debate focused only on Katz’s prices. However, what is written suggests that its prices are not really higher, not compared to other very famous delis in the city. The text points out that the price for a Reuben at Katz’s is “on par with other iconic NYC delis,” like Sarge’s. It is not out of line with theirs.
For instance, Sarge’s Deli is in Murray Hill in the city. It charges $31.45 for a Reuben too. That is plus tax on top of it. Their pastrami sandwich costs $26.95, a bit less than Katz’s one. Another very known spot, 2nd Avenue Deli is mentioned. It charges $29 for its pastrami sandwiches for people.
These comparisons seem to show that the nearly $30 cost for a top pastrami or corned beef sandwich is not unique to Katz’s, at least not among the old, long-established delis in New York City. The price seems high, yes, but it appears to fit within a certain group of famous delis known for their food quality and long history. This context helps to explain Katz’s pricing. It is not just a case of overcharging; rather, it reflects what you pay in a part of the city’s food market.
Okay, let’s talk about something else now. People do argue about that costly sandwich, sure. New York City’s food scene is a big, complex picture. It’s not just about spending a lot on a single bite. Finding great food at a low cost is what the city is about. Value means everything here, not just at famous delis. Everyday spots and simple meals define NYC living.
The fuss over Katz’s shows a rule of dining in New York. Good food can suit any mood and any budget here. You can easily find fast, cheap, and truly satisfying street food. Corner stores sell humble but great heroes. There are many ways to find the soul of NYC’s food culture at a low cost. This huge range makes New York special, you see. Iconic food can be found around every corner, always accessible.
Related posts:
An Eater’s Guide to New York City
Famed NYC restaurant grilled over $30 sandwich: ‘Really overrated’
